This is a search-engine-friendly text mirror of the TalkBass Forums

VIEW FULL LIVE VERSION : Aluminum Bass on eBay


mr sprocket
02-23-2007, 06:50 PM
I stumbled across this aluminum bass on eBay and was wondering if anyone else had seen one of these before.

http://cgi.ebay.com/VERY-OLD-ALUMINUM-UPRIGHT-BASS_W0QQitemZ110095866594

mxr255
02-23-2007, 08:58 PM
i own an old Aluminum Bass. Not a good sound but holds up to the dry winters well (lol). I use it more as a conversation peice. SOrry I don't have any more info.

dchan
02-23-2007, 09:13 PM
I believe it is probably an American made aluminum bass.

The Americans and Germans both made aluminum basses a quite a while ago. The main difference between the two was that the American basses were welded together, while the German basses were riveted. The riveting, of course, allows for luthiers to repair the inside of the bass if necessary.

jazz bass guy
02-23-2007, 11:56 PM
Ray Brown told a story about when he was a kid, they would use the school's aluminum bass for a toboggan. I've never seen one.

fingers
02-24-2007, 01:18 AM
I've played two and they both sounded terrible. A fun novelty but I had to use one at a gig. It as a long night.

Jason Sypher
02-24-2007, 05:55 AM
I know a guy who plays one exclusively. It's loud as hell for one. It's not the worst sound in the world if you are just listening to it as it's own thing and not expecting wood. It's impervious to the elements. But in the end, I always wonder why he doesn't get himself a wood bass as well. I think that it is so powerful that it's almost difficult to play a wood one after that, it just doesn't have as much sound (even though its a much more musical sound). I wouldn't recommend one to anyone.

KentuckyJim
02-24-2007, 12:32 PM
Hey, I just looked at the picture on ebay. This one might be my old one. The peg box looks kinda crooked like my old one.

I bought an all aluminum welded bass with aluminum neck. I had painted mine white with flames. It was solid as a rock. I always played it amplified with a K&K rockabilly set up. It still sounded kinda boxy. These basses can be very loud, but acousticly sound like crap.

So if you are doing a loud rock thing fill the body with foam and slap a pick-up on it. If it's your first and only upright, buy something nice instead.

mr sprocket
02-24-2007, 04:35 PM
If I lived closer I might be tempted. It would look great with so flames. I could use for rockabilly stuff.

dimcc
05-18-2007, 03:52 PM
I play a 1929 Pfretschner aluminum bodied 3/4. I was lucky enough a few years back to correspond with an old gentleman who was the youngest in that family who said that the year 1929 as their rep in NYC was the best year of his life -- a commentary, I suppose, on the war and life in East Germany, if selling musical instruments after the crash was great! He said that they built the aluminum instruments in order to avoid having to re-work every bass that they shipped, as the humidity and temperature changes in shipping wrecked them, as well as in an attempt to get the school market because of durability. These basses have a conventional neck, fingerboard, some wooden internal bracing, and a wooden soundpost and seats. The top is screwed to the sides, which are crimped to the back. Mine is rough looking -- I was once told that it had to have been taken by force, as it could not have been part of a mercantile transaction. The sound is, I think, as good as a cheap plywood bass, but not as good as a carved one. I love it.

dimcc
05-18-2007, 03:59 PM
I play a 1929 Pfretschner aluminum bodied 3/4. I was lucky enough a few years back to correspond with an old gentleman who was the youngest in that family who said that the year 1929 as their rep in NYC was the best year of his life -- a commentary, I suppose, on the war and life in East Germany, if selling musical instruments after the crash was great! He said that they built the aluminum instruments in order to avoid having to re-work every bass that they shipped, as the humidity and temperature changes in shipping wrecked them, as well as in an attempt to get the school market because of durability. These basses have a conventional neck, fingerboard, some wooden internal bracing, and a wooden soundpost and seats. The top is screwed to the sides, which are crimped to the back. Mine is rough looking -- I was once told that it had to have been taken by force, as it could not have been part of a mercantile transaction. The sound is, I think, as good as a cheap plywood bass, but not as good as a carved one. I love it.

The Aluminum Musical Instrument Company of Ann Arbor, Mich., later taken over by G.C. Conn, had some 550 welded aluminum basses produced by Alcoa between 1928 and 1958. These insturments only had wood in the fingerboard and soundpost. These were initially marketed under the name "The Collegian" and later under the name Joseph Maddy, who was, I believe, the gentleman who came up with the design.

I'd love to get my hands on one of the Maddy basses -- anyone who has a line on one please send me a note.

RWP
05-18-2007, 04:06 PM
Wish I could have seen that. :bawl:

bajocallao
05-18-2007, 04:06 PM
When in High School(early 90's) I went to an after school music program at Harlem School of the Arts
they had one
it was horrible
my choice was either the "tank bass" (which is what us kids at the time nicknamed it) or a 1/2 size plywood that had no endpin
Now I was by no means a tall kid but the tank always won the tose up

TroyK
05-18-2007, 04:07 PM
I saw someone busking with one in Pike Place Market last week. They're a cool piece of history. I wonder how much also had to do with economics. A lot of things were made with aluminum in the late 40s/early 50's because there was surplus from military aircraft assembly lines. My furnace, for example, just missed flying sorties over Germany by a few years.

I don't know about owning a bass that requires a tetanus shot, though.

rick123
05-18-2007, 04:53 PM
I have one of the ALCOA aluminum basses. It was used in the school system here for years. Then one of the teachers used it in a community dance band; then I acquired it, mostly as a novelty. It was professionally set up in the '80's even including a wedge to increase the neck angle. It had a strange Buck Rogers endpin which I replaced with a modern one, saving the original, of course. The bass sounds awful, kind of like poorly made steel drums, but it's quite a head-turner with the faux-wood finish and all.
Upton has some great info, patents and pic's of these beasts on their website. One of these days I'm going to put this thing on eBay too.

Eric Rene Roy
05-18-2007, 05:53 PM
These were initially marketed under the name "The Collegian" and later under the name Joseph Maddy, who was, I believe, the gentleman who came up with the design.The ALCOA Patent sites Burdick.

http://www.uptonbass.com/burdickviolinpat1941595.pdf

Cathead
05-20-2007, 02:07 AM
I did find this picture of an aluminum bass.

http://www.laurasandage.com/images/rayplaysbass.jpg

fish slapper
05-31-2007, 06:37 PM
I know someone who owns an aluminum bass. It actually has decent acoustic volume. I've heard stories that some of these basses were used in traveling navy bands where sea air, etc. might be rought on wood.:confused:

superman
05-31-2007, 08:51 PM
My mentor Joe Zinkan who was one of the Ateam studio players here in Nashville in the 60s and 70s,used a aluminum bass back in the 30s and 40s with Roy Acuff.
He told me back then the bass rode the car top, and solid basses didnt fair too well,his old carved german(which I now own)was in a wreck in 37 which the car flipped 3 times,he had a new neck put in it and it still sounds great,,as for the aluminum bass he said if it got wet you just poured the water out and went on stage.It too was wrecked in the late 40s they forgot to tie it down and it blew off the car and hit the road on its back,,Joe said at the time no one could do much welding or repair on aluminum,,but one bright fellow had a idea how to pop the dent out,He took a bit of gas and poured in the bass and threw a match too it and Joe swears it straightend right back out,I've seen the old bass its in the Grand Ole opry Museum at the Opry house and sure enough you can see the back has been dented up some.
Theres no wonder so many basses are in such bad shape

txstatebass
05-31-2007, 10:17 PM
We have one here at Texas State we let the intro string methods kids use. We call it "the Canoe." It's a hoot. I want to paint it battleship grey and put the call letter's DB101 on the side (being the former Navy man I am)

james condino
02-11-2008, 09:49 AM
I wrote a detailed article on these basses last spring for American Lutherie magazine. It involved about three years research with myself, the Smithsonian, The Heinze Museum, and about eight other sources. I seem to be the "Aluminum bass dork" to contact if you've got questions these days and I see about 4-6 AlCoAs and a few Pfretschners in my shop per year. They all have their pros and cons, but everyone agrees that they are TOUGH!!!!I first got involved with them when I used to run commercial river expeditions and the crew happened to have a nice little band. We got tired of simply having a washtub bass and wanted something tough in the slot canyons at night.

There are a few images on my website and I've got a good database on the AlCoAs. If you've got one, I can give you the real story and help you ID the date, so feel free to give me a call. I regularly also broker sales for other folks. I'm not trying to compromise any site rules, just offering up information on some very obscure instruments that seem to have a closet of misinformation following them around. I wouldn't reccomend one for your primary instrument, but if you've got a quiver of basses, they fill a void that others can't fill.

j.
www.condino.com

RED5
02-11-2008, 11:44 AM
I've heard stories that some of these basses were used in traveling navy bands where sea air, etc. might be rough on wood.:

Ditto to that, I 'd heard the navy used them shipboard on Capital ships, where the band played to dignitaries and for special events. Seems like a good idea, I live near the ocean and every season everything wood in the house needs attention.

MonetBass
02-11-2008, 11:57 AM
My middle school music dept. had one, and luckily no one had to play it. They're on par with the box 'cellos, which unfortunately some people DID have to play (ugh). My college music dept. had one too, and when one of the other bassist was getting ready to graduate, we floated it out on the campus pond one night. The cops found it not five minutes later and it was returned to the music department, much to our dismay.

william whalen
03-03-2010, 12:15 AM
Hi, I have had for many years an aluminium Alcoa , 7/8 upright . When I came across it it still had the faux wood paint ,as poor as the original finish was, when I aquired it ,it was so mouldering, disgusting looking ,I had it stripped and profesionally repainted matte black. Perhaps I should have just polished. it.Anyway, I am thinking of selling it.It is in excellent condition EXCEPEPT , the fingerboard is missing, and though I thought of making one in my machine shop, I am sure that like many things, it is not so hard to do, but very easy to do wrong resulting in an enourmous waste of time. It may be that the cost of a pro doing the work may be more than the piece is worth. I see many conflicting feelings towards these limited production units, they love them/ they hate them! One other question, where is the serial # Any reply would be greatly appeiciated. Thanx Willy

BassFace55
03-03-2010, 09:32 AM
I also heard they were made for the traveling Armed Forces bands.Held up better than wood