This is a search-engine-friendly text mirror of the TalkBass Forums

VIEW FULL LIVE VERSION : Got a bunch of really nice wood...


Alex
11-27-2007, 10:21 PM
About 6 or 8 months ago, we had to cut down a few black cherry trees on our farm to make room for something. I was still considering building my own bass back then, so I asked them to set me aside the best wood. I just put it in my basement and, when my bass building plan died, I just forgot about it.

So I just looked at this stuff again today. It's really good looking, great grain and flames...it would make some really nice looking tops. I have 2 big slabs that are each about 6.5'x1.5'x1.5" and I just realized that these are probably worth a good amount as tonewood. What exactly they are worth I don't know. Anybody have any idea?

Second - is there anything I need to do to them to make them sell-able or more ready for use? Any drying besides just around the house?

Oh and how would black cherry sound on a bass anywhere? body, neck, fretboard....any clue? I think someone told me once that is tone is kind of deep and dark? I don't really know.

Thanks guys

~Alex

luzceloffan
11-27-2007, 10:46 PM
You should ship that wood to me :D :bassist::hiding:

Jonsbasses
11-28-2007, 12:25 AM
You might get a better price estimate with pictures of the wood. And I can guarantee that it is not 10% or less moisture content yet, if black cherry is a hard wood (which is my guess) it will need about 18+ months to get down to being near fully dry at 1.5" thick.

Alex
11-28-2007, 05:54 PM
You might get a better price estimate with pictures of the wood. And I can guarantee that it is not 10% or less moisture content yet, if black cherry is a hard wood (which is my guess) it will need about 18+ months to get down to being near fully dry at 1.5" thick.Isn't there a way to dry it quickly like in a vacuum or something? I think I remember something like that.

dman_113
11-28-2007, 06:34 PM
Your thinking of a "Vacuum Kiln" and yes it will dry wood a lot quicker than air drying you'd just have to find someone willing to do it for you. If you have a wood processing facility near you they might do it for a fee.

DavidRavenMoon
11-28-2007, 06:36 PM
Cherry is real nice for basses. I started using it back in the early 90's just because I liked the board I found. I hadn't seen it used much back then. It's a heavy wood, but it has a nice warm, but tight, tone. It's similar to maple, but not as bright. It's not dark sounding.

You have to sticker that wood for couple of years, or get it kiln dried.

Here's two basses made from the same board. Notice how different the figure is!

http://www.david-schwab.com/images/SGD_Scorpios_back.jpg

T2W
11-28-2007, 06:42 PM
Dammit, here we go again.

Ok, first off, the 1 year per inch rule is crap to me. Pine will obviously dry faster than Maple, Thats part of the reason why its less expensive than Maple. 60% of all the energy (and by energy, I mean physical labor, costs, etc..) is in the drying process, from the time the faller cuts the tree and gets lifted out of there with an aircrane, to when the customer picks up a board from the shelf at Home Depot. thats a lot. Ash is also cheaper than Maple because it dries with a lot less checks and cracks than Maple. Maple is a real pita, in my experience anyway. Spalted Maple is a breeze and so is Walnut and Ash, but wet Maple really sucks.

Anyways, all that to say that there exists a lot of methods when it comes to drying wood. Commercial facilities usually use steam kilns, they are quite efficient, but expensive, I piled and loaded tons and tons and tons of birch into these huge kilns, they were about 40 x 40 x 30. Ive mentioned here before, I put my huge Ash slabs in a small area under the stairs in the house, I threw in a dehumidifier in there, full throttle 24/7 with a small fan to keep the air circulating. I maintained the humidity level at 22%, which is excellent conditions to dry wood, and it was about 37-40 degrees celsius (aint american). after 2 weeks in the 'kiln', the Ash was at 7%MC, I was quite surprised. I bought a small delmhorst Jlite thingie to read the MC in the wood. 7% was right on for me, so I took it out and cut it all into half a dozen Body blanks. I still got a nice big piece air drying for the moment. No idea what I will do with it. If you wanna read more about the subject, check out http://www.ca.uky.edu/agc/pubs/for/for55/for55.htm great information in there. Good Luck and please show pics !! Peace.
-Mario-

eleonn
11-28-2007, 08:04 PM
I still got a nice big piece air drying for the moment. No idea what I will do with it.

I do have some ideas Mario... lets say that you could send a little 40cm X 50cm x 5cm piece to South America... there is no ash there!!! :hiding:

T2W
11-28-2007, 08:20 PM
It would have to be in two pieces though Enrique. PM me.

RAHAZ
11-28-2007, 08:31 PM
Isn't there a way to dry it quickly like in a vacuum or something? I think I remember something like that.

You could always sent it out here to the desert. It'll take the moisture out of anything quick. :)

Jonsbasses
11-28-2007, 09:04 PM
if black cherry is a hard wood (which is my guess)

Dammit, here we go again. Pine will obviously dry faster than Maple,

Pine is not a hard wood, the general rule only applies towards hard woods. ;) Read up on the different kinds of woods and the general rules that applies to them, hence the "general" part, it is not meant to be specific. No hard feelings Mario, just helping you learn! Check out "Wood identification and use" by Terry Porter, it's a great book.

Alex
11-28-2007, 10:19 PM
Good Luck and please show pics !!Alright I'm on it.

Any other experiences with Black Cherry? Like David said I've heard that it has a warm-ish sound. I take it it's more of a body wood than a fingerboard or neck wood? Sounds like its comparable to rosewood in sound.

tjclem
11-29-2007, 05:15 AM
I like Cherry too it is just that no customers seem to be interested in it. So mine just sits around....t

T2W
11-29-2007, 07:19 AM
No hard feelings Mario, just helping you learn!

Ha ! thats good. what I meant was basically, the humidity isnt the same in Arizona as it is in the province of Quebec where it gets to 90% in the summer. Im pretty damn sure a dude would be more succesful in air drying wood in Houston, than in Montreal, or Bangkok. I guess its a very general rule, Ive had a slab of ash air drying for a bit over a year now, its 3 inches thick, and its at 11%. 1 year per inch? quite irrelevant if you ask me ! It really depends on where you store the wood, Humidity level in your area, inside or out, the amount of air circulating through the pieces..... As mentioned a bit higher, I piled and loaded and touched and smelled and dried literally tons and tons of birch and a bit of maple, no hard feelings dude, but I think im starting to understand the idea of drying wood.... :smug:

check out the basses Ive been building, all of them have wood that I cut in the forest in them, whether its a spalted Maple top, or white Ash body.

FBB Custom
11-29-2007, 08:54 AM
As others have said, cherry is not as valuable as a tone wood as you might think. Electric instrument makers will have a hard time finding a buyer since it is neither an "exotic" (cocobolo, etc) nor an "established tonewood" (ash or maple). The acoustic instrument makers won't touch it if it's not quartersawn and perfectly seasoned.

Furniture/cabinet makers would eat the stuff up. Take a look at http://www.curlymaple.com/cherry.shtml to see what the highest grades of cherry sell for to the fine furniture crowd.

DavidRavenMoon
11-29-2007, 11:08 AM
Alright I'm on it.

Any other experiences with Black Cherry? Like David said I've heard that it has a warm-ish sound. I take it it's more of a body wood than a fingerboard or neck wood? Sounds like its comparable to rosewood in sound.

It makes a nice neck. It's very similar to maple, just a bit warmer sounding. Kind of like soft maple. I think rosewood is a lot denser and darker sounding. I like to think of it as a cross between maple and mahogany.

It would probably make a good fingerboard, but you would have to apply a finish to it like a maple board.

Alex
12-03-2007, 09:42 PM
PICS!

http://photos-a.ak.facebook.com/photos-ak-sf2p/v150/115/123/1145101597/n1145101597_30787288_1147.jpg
http://photos-d.ak.facebook.com/photos-ak-sf2p/v150/115/123/1145101597/n1145101597_30787291_1546.jpg
http://photos-b.ak.facebook.com/photos-ak-sf2p/v150/115/123/1145101597/n1145101597_30787293_1805.jpg
http://photos-d.ak.facebook.com/photos-ak-sf2p/v150/115/123/1145101597/n1145101597_30787295_2067.jpg

That last pic shows some random scuffing or something but that can easily be sanded off I think.

This isn't all of it, just some random points on it.

~Alex

FBB Custom
12-04-2007, 09:02 AM
If you want to sell it then it looks to me like cabinet makers are the way to go. They like very wide stuff as it's hard to find and it looks like good quality material. The acoustic guys probably will pass as it's not quartersawn and personally I know I would have a hard time selling it on a bass. People want walnut, mahogany, alder... If I had it I would be trying to figure out where to fit a table saw so I could make furniture out of it.

Try posting on woodweb or craig's list. You're lucky to have some really nice stuff.

Eric618
12-04-2007, 09:06 AM
Here's my Conklin with a carved Cherry top. Very cool looking wood, IMO...

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c8/Eric618/knobs_1.jpg

Yellow
12-04-2007, 10:57 AM
Dammit, here we go again.

Ok, first off, the 1 year per inch rule is crap to me. Pine will obviously dry faster than Maple, Thats part of the reason why its less expensive than Maple. 60% of all the energy (and by energy, I mean physical labor, costs, etc..) is in the drying process, from the time the faller cuts the tree and gets lifted out of there with an aircrane, to when the customer picks up a board from the shelf at Home Depot. thats a lot. Ash is also cheaper than Maple because it dries with a lot less checks and cracks than Maple. Maple is a real pita, in my experience anyway. Spalted Maple is a breeze and so is Walnut and Ash, but wet Maple really sucks.....

-Mario-

TW2 is an experienced wood scavenger like myself;),
I agree it is unpredictable how long it takes to dry wood best is to get a moisture meter and test as you go. Ventilation is the key.

From the pics it seems good avarage cherry for furniture I cant tell if there is any curl or flame in it from those pics I have some of this kind of cherry and it dryed fast to a stable condition 8%

As for tone I dont know, but in furniture it is often mixed with Alder and Red Alder is used to fake cherry, this cherry is only a touch harder actual cherry tree that s has cherrys is much harder then the wild variety.

T2W
12-04-2007, 11:37 AM
[QUOTE=Yellow;4985576]I agree it is unpredictable how long it takes to dry wood best is to get a moisture meter and test as you go.QUOTE]

I think the Jlite goes for about 160, probably more in the states nowadays.... hihihi. There are some cheaper ones for sure. www.delmhorst.com another important thing to consider is the MC at the time the tree is cut, not all trees hold the same amount of water too. Another reason why I try to get trees that are already dead, accelerates the drying time.

Alex, that is some nice lookin wood, it looks really nice on the Conklin. How is working with cherry anyways? ive never used it.

Yellow, how do you dry your Maple? not your spalted maple, Ive had no problems drying mine, just ordinary Maple. It seems so hard to dry properly without getting checks all over the ends, even if its sealed beyond belief. Id like to be able to avoid the loss when resawing. Thanks

-Mario-

pilotjones
12-04-2007, 11:55 AM
I agree it is unpredictable how long it takes to dry wood best is to get a moisture meter and test as you go.

I think the Jlite goes for about 160, probably more in the states nowadays.... hihihi. There are some cheaper ones for sure. www.delmhorst.com I believe there are plans on the FPL website for a moisture meter you can build.

Yellow
12-04-2007, 12:03 PM
[QUOTE=Yellow;4985576]I agree it is unpredictable how long it takes to dry wood best is to get a moisture meter and test as you go.QUOTE]

Yellow, how do you dry your Maple? not your spalted maple, Ive had no problems drying mine, just ordinary Maple. It seems so hard to dry properly without getting checks all over the ends, even if its sealed beyond belief. Id like to be able to avoid the loss when resawing. Thanks

-Mario-

Yo, I have an open post and beam barn I satck it there with spacers for the first couple of months, You know yourself that wet maple can grow mold and mushrooms it is stored in a warm place rightaway, so I let it get well ventilated first then move it into my shop and restack it to let it dry with a small electric heater that runs all the time so that my shop is warm and dry (electric baseboard heaters suck moisture like crazy)

I will take a few pics,

T2W we should compile a thread of cutting and storing tips for everybody to have a look and contibute their ideas.

I sent you pm with a solar solution, check it out but here is the link anyway,
http://www.woodmizer.com/us/secondary/kilns/SolarDry3000/solar.aspx

Yellow
12-04-2007, 12:04 PM
I believe there are plans on the FPL website for a moisture meter you can build.

Cool I am sharing one with a friend, lee valley model.

T2W
12-04-2007, 02:25 PM
[QUOTE=Yellow;4985831]T2W we should compile a thread of cutting and storing tips for everybody to have a look and contibute their ideas.[QUOTE]

We really should, drying wood is a long process but I believe its worth it, especially if its for your own bass, its even cooler if you cut the wood yourself. Ill PM you tonight and we could share some ideas, eventually post all the info and maybe itll end up in the how to section. (How-to cut your own tree and build a bass with it....)

Alex
12-04-2007, 09:49 PM
acoustic guys probably will pass as it's not quartersawnIt's still usable for a bass neck or body even though it's not quartersawn, eh?

DavidRavenMoon
12-04-2007, 11:51 PM
As others have said, cherry is not as valuable as a tone wood as you might think. Electric instrument makers will have a hard time finding a buyer since it is neither an "exotic" (cocobolo, etc) nor an "established tonewood" (ash or maple). The acoustic instrument makers won't touch it if it's not quartersawn and perfectly seasoned.

I've been seeing a lot of solid bodies made from cherry, and necks too.

When I started using it back in the mid 90's, I didn't see any other basses made with cherry.

Now over at MIMF I see cherry used for necks and bodies on a regular basis.

Things like cocobolo would be a top wood, not really a body wood.

Here's birdseye maple and zebra wood over cherry.. plenty exotic, and the great warm tone of cherry. :)

http://www.sgd-lutherie.com/images/SGD_Scorpios_front.jpg