1/2 Size for an Adult?

[Lombax]

I've owned a 3/4 upright that ive been playing off and on for roughly 10 years. I found an engelhardt 1/2 size bass for sale and I am interested in buying it. I play a mix of folk and jazz in an acoustic trio. The 1/2 size seems more portable and I was wondering if it would be a big difference switching from a 3/4 to a 1/2. Any thoughts, suggestions, cautions? Please let me know what you think. I am 5'8". Thanks

[fdeck]

I am not much taller than you, and get around a 3/4 just fine. I think it's more a matter of technique than the size of your body. Also, a KC Strings Bass Buggie will make your bass much more portable.

My own thoughts are along these lines. I am not a full time pro, but just a day jobber and weekend warrior. I feel so lucky to play at all, that I want to treat every gig like it might be my last. So I will ask you from that perspective: If you've got a 3/4 bass in the house, are you really going to take out the 1/2 size?

If at all possible, give these basses a long trial side by side.

[Lombax]

bmp

[Hector Wolff]

I spent quite some time playing my daughter's 1/2 size bass (which was really a pretty good student instrument - easy to play and in good condition), before I bought my own 3/4.

The string length was significantly shorter on the 1/2, and the volume was noticeably lower. Not to mention it was difficult to get into a normal playing position (though I expect with an extra long end pin that could be solved).

Additionally most 1/2's are beginner instruments, unless your current 3/4 is not a very good instrument to begin with, I expect you'll be trading off some tonal quality as well.

As for portability? I have never found a 3/4 to be too heavy or hard to get around, and I am a not very fit 5' 11".

I would expect it's a poor trade off, unless your current instrument is poor and you happen to come across an unusually good 1/2.