Quality of Double bass
What would be the price and brand of double bass that has comparable quality to a fender american standard strat in guitar?
I had something totally awesome to say to this, but i think it would be better to ask,
Can we just lock this one right now?
Unhelpfully there are no words..........
Let's rephrase this: What is a good quality mass produced double bass? You probably need to eliminate the made in the US part, as there are probably not any.
Having said that, I'm going to try. You can't compare a bass guitar, quality wise, to a double bass. Ever. In any context. Hence unfortunately, there is simply no answer to your question.
Actually, I think there can be a comparison... in that a DB will be priced at about 5x to 8x as a BG of similar value in that category. eg. Entry level BG, about $300, entry level DB about $1500-$2400. Continue from there. A $1000 BG, is similar to a $5000 - $8000 DB, in regards to quality of tool used by a musician in professional circumstances.
I'd say an Upton ply or Shen SB80 is in the ballpark as a comparable to a US made Strat.
The setup and finish are probably a little better than the Strat, but either of those instruments should be lore or less grab and go with some setup adjustments to make a better match between player and bass.
while it's actually easier to compare drums to EB than DB to EB, i'll try and be mature and give a real answer to this "east to be snoody about" question..
there are quite often for sale in the $4000-6000 range old(ish) german or tyrolean basses, i'd say these count. my bass is ~100 year old tyrol flatback and it's a good quality bass with a pleasing tone, i'd put it in this category. or maybe shen's middle-of the line hybrids? or for that matter, any decent (upton or similar??) hybrid bass will have a nice sound and pretty much work in most situations, and could easily be a top notch players backup bass.
the big issue is that all DBs are unique. nobody can go out and buy a bass just like mine. even two basses of the same exact description- for example, who else has a ~100 year old tyrolean flatback? (lets pretend someone in the front row just raised their hand and said "i do.") do you think that bass sounds and feels and behaves exactly like mine? no, im sure it doesnt!
even two basses from the same maker, say two upton gary karr basses, both made this year, they may sound totally different.
so, there is no "real" equal. but there are many good quality workhorse basses than get people results they're happy with.
What I meant was a double bass that's got a fine sound with a 'reasonable' price range, regardless of it's orgin country or finish and stuff. But I now see that that is really hard to compare too.
I am a newbie in double bass so this was hepful enough.
Resonable Double bass? Try a KC Strings. Like the other models they start at ~1500 and go up. You can get a fully carved for 3200. They all play incredible, as they have to. In this day and age a reputable shop has to have competititve instruments. People talk about Upton and Shen, but KC Strings gives you as much bang for your buck.
I think something the OP has to realize is that electric guitars and basses are kind of the bottom of the instrument market. How much does a decent trumpet or sax cost for a college freshmen, and then for a graduate?
Ever seen a marimba for sale? A lot of these electric players don't realize the scope of how much instruments cost outside of the rock shop.
Realize that 1500 is reasonable for someone with a decent income, and KC Strings does payment plans.
The point of entry is higher for some things than others.
Thanks for rephrasing. In the BG world you can make an easy prediction of what an instrument will sound like. A Sadowsky sounds like a Sadowsky, a fender Jazz sounds like a Fender Jazz. You can tell them apart because they are consistent. You can predict bang for buck easily..
In the DB world while there is sort of a consistency, really each bass can have a uniqueness that you mightn't suspect. Then add into that string choice, set up (huge differences there) and it's difficult to predict exactly what an instrument will sound like, beyond ok, good and oh my. Then there is capability of the player. The best players can make mediocre instruments sound good. And vice versa with say me and a 40,000 instrument lol.
Be prepared to be a bit shocked as to the cost of any double bass above what is euphemistically called a student bass in terms of quality.
My advice is to maybe hire one for a bit, get a few lessons on it and then try out a few others. You will then be able to make a more informed choice.
Good luck with your search.
More seriously, as has been noted, there is no comparison between a guitar and a doublebass. Much of the advice you've been given has been of the "what's the least expensive decent thing you can buy" variety.
If you want to play the big bass, follow it verbatim. Lots of hard-won experience went into the advice you were freely given.
|All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:23 AM.|
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.