TalkBass Forums

TalkBass Forums (http://www.talkbass.com/forum/)
-   Amps [BG] (http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f15/)
-   -   Bass head vs Preamp/power amp (http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f15/bass-head-vs-preamp-power-amp-948220/)

iwearpumas 01-12-2013 11:42 PM

Bass head vs Preamp/power amp
 
How many bass players play out of bass heads, or how many play out of preamp/power amp combinations. I have both, but lately my power amp has been flipping out on me. I notice that the volume control on my power amp has no effect on how much power it pushes out. I dont want to get a new power amp though. Maybe ill just get rid of the power amp and buy a second bass head.

craig.p 01-13-2013 01:55 AM

I'll use either separates or an all-in-1, depending on what's required for a particular job.

Non-functioning gain control should be an easy fix. Might be as simple as a broken or worn out potentiometer, or a broken solder joint at one of its legs.

vishuddha 01-13-2013 07:48 AM

I've got my BBE Bmax preamp and Crown XLS 1500 power amp in the mail right now... so take that as you will. But I really just like the look and versatility of pre/power... people are just as happy with an all-in-one.

RickenBoogie 01-13-2013 08:07 AM

I use bass heads, always have. I don't know what the ratio is between all bass players, but I suspect the majority also use heads. That said, I agree, your poweramp would probably be repaired for alot less money than a new bass amp would cost.

JonnyAngle 01-13-2013 08:13 AM

I use a GK mb500 but bypass the preamp. I use geb7 s to eq or different ods with eqs. I like having the option to use the amps pre if I want to bring a simple setup

Mr_Music90 01-13-2013 08:13 AM

Okay, I'm a bit new on this, sorry about the noobieness, but can someone explain to me, how much different will a poweramp be compared to a bass head?

Zooberwerx 01-13-2013 08:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iwearpumas (Post 13711290)
How many bass players play out of bass heads, or how many play out of preamp/power amp combinations. I have both, but lately my power amp has been flipping out on me. I notice that the volume control on my power amp has no effect on how much power it pushes out. I dont want to get a new power amp though. Maybe ill just get rid of the power amp and buy a second bass head.

Tell us more about the hardware in question and how you have it cabled / connected with the preamp. There is no true volume control on a power amp...they are attenuators which help gain-match the power amp with the preamp and that's a gross over-simplification. I see more operator errors as opposed to truly broken or wonky equipment.

...and to answer your question, I use pre / power configs only. Overall, the wattage is cheaper (yucks / bucks) plus I can roll pre's in and out of the rig as I see fit.

Riis

FloridaThump 01-13-2013 08:29 AM

I use a pre/power for large gigs (BBE 383 & Samson SX1800) and I have a bass head that I use for rehearsal/small gigs. For me, not really a huge proponent either way. I little more control/flexibility with a pre/power setup. However, the power available via the pre/post route in terms of dollar/watt is fairly significant. Additionally, most power amps have a crossover option if you want separate lows and mids/highs. I don't think one is necessarily better than the other, simply a matter of preference.

SERPENT865 01-13-2013 10:29 AM

i do both

RickenBoogie 01-13-2013 01:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_Music90 (Post 13712057)
Okay, I'm a bit new on this, sorry about the noobieness, but can someone explain to me, how much different will a poweramp be compared to a bass head?

A bass "head", is an all-in-one unit that contains a preamp and a poweramp. A "combo amp" contains both of those PLUS a speaker. A poweramp is just that, a poweramp. It requires a preamp in front of it, and speakers after it.

Gearhead17 01-13-2013 02:28 PM

Separate power amps run clean - If you are adjusted to listening to old Acoustic heads, all-tube power sections, and other amps where the power section is not clean, you may be disappointed. Whatever you put into the clean power amp is going to come out clean/clear sounding. For clean style bass tones, you really can't lose. If you want dirty tones, overdrive or whatever, the pre-amp, or a pedals/other rack gear will have to deliver it. Don't expect those items to get close to a tube power section..... However, if you use pedals all the time and like them, you should be just fine.:bassist:

RadioactiveGuy4 01-13-2013 10:31 PM

I just made the switch to a pre/power amp set up. I find its much eaiser to get more Watts for less money. Plus most power amps can be run down to 2ohms or be bridged to get more power out of them. This give me a lot of options as far as running more cabs. Lets face facts. Who doesn't want the ability to run two 8x10s. Sure its way to loud to be practical but its awesome.

JimmyM 01-13-2013 11:36 PM

Heads exclusively for me. Never once owned a pre-power rig. I figured why bother since they're all bundled up nicely like that? But it doesn't matter...sometimes your stuff works and sometimes it doesn't. Just have to measure the repair/replace ratio and decide what's the best way to cut your losses.

gurensan 01-22-2013 08:09 PM

I really don't hate heads, but I prefer the flexibility of pre/power.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gearhead17 (Post 13713723)
Separate power amps run clean - If you are adjusted to listening to old Acoustic heads, all-tube power sections, and other amps where the power section is not clean, you may be disappointed. Whatever you put into the clean power amp is going to come out clean/clear sounding. For clean style bass tones, you really can't lose. If you want dirty tones, overdrive or whatever, the pre-amp, or a pedals/other rack gear will have to deliver it. Don't expect those items to get close to a tube power section..... However, if you use pedals all the time and like them, you should be just fine.:bassist:

^^ I also like pushing my power. Hard to do if you're carting around an SS amp designed never to permit itself to be pushed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by RadioactiveGuy4 (Post 13715711)
I just made the switch to a pre/power amp set up. I find its much eaiser to get more Watts for less money. Plus most power amps can be run down to 2ohms or be bridged to get more power out of them. This give me a lot of options as far as running more cabs. Lets face facts. Who doesn't want the ability to run two 8x10s. Sure its way to loud to be practical but its awesome.

^^ and yeah 810s. Nothing looks cooler behind a bassist on stage.. cept, perhaps, a sulking guitar player.

Mykk 01-22-2013 09:06 PM

I'm doing both, at the same time.

Floyd Eye 01-22-2013 09:08 PM

Pre/power for me. That will change if I can ever afford an SVT

seamonkey 01-22-2013 09:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iwearpumas (Post 13711290)
How many bass players play out of bass heads, or how many play out of preamp/power amp combinations. I have both, but lately my power amp has been flipping out on me. I notice that the volume control on my power amp has no effect on how much power it pushes out. I dont want to get a new power amp though. Maybe ill just get rid of the power amp and buy a second bass head.

Knobs on bass heads sometimes break too.

Depends on your pre-amp, and what you want, but most rack mount pre-amps would be designed to pair with a true power amp. Heads may have too much coloration, they all add it. Mostly you can plug your pre-amp into the effects return on a head, but this don't always bypass all the coloration added by the head. Try it, see if you like it.

Sartori 01-22-2013 11:51 PM

I play through a bass head. Just how things ended up for me.

Franklin229 01-23-2013 05:34 AM

I use separates. Just my take on things:
Always prefer the flexibility of being able to upgrade individual components w/o throwing out the whole unit, I think there are sonic advantages to having simpler components vs "all in ones", and last, I think there are companies that excel at making either amps or preamps but not too many that do both really well.

bassman10096 01-23-2013 06:12 AM

I use both, but I've run into worse trouble when an integrated head craps out on a gig than when a pre or power amp misbehaves. With a bass head - when it's dead, its dead. However, with a pre/power arrangement there's usually enough back up gear for the PA that I can replace or reroute around the malfunctioning unit. I have several pre's and several power amps to use when something's in the shop, too. Overall reliability is same or similar for pre/power vs integrated head.

As far as sound goes, I like both - usually I use either a Mesa M6 head or an Eden Traveler pre through a Crown XLS2500. BTW: The Eden/Crown rack is considerably lighter than the Mesa head. :cool:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:23 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.