TalkBass Forums

TalkBass Forums (http://www.talkbass.com/forum/)
-   Amps [BG] (http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f15/)
-   -   Running power amp with tube head. (http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f15/running-power-amp-tube-head-965117/)

creis2 03-08-2013 11:03 AM

Running power amp with tube head.
 
I tried to do some research, but I haven't found anything that helped.

I'm looking at a 100W tube head. It should cover 99% of gigs, but the idea of possibly running the preamp into a high power power amp for trying different setups interests me.

I know a tube amp has to be plugged into a load at all times.

Is there a simple dummy load solution, then use the preamp out into a poweramp?

Or is this just a bad idea all around?

Layman's terms please :D.

Primakurtz 03-08-2013 11:17 AM

Check out the THD Hotplate: http://www.thdelectronics.com/produc..._hotplate.html

Or, the Weber Attenuators: http://www.tedweber.com/atten.htm

It is a very good approach - worked well for Eddie Van Halen!

creis2 03-08-2013 11:23 AM

Ouch, kind of expensive.

I'm better off getting the VT Bass DI when it comes out.

B-string 03-08-2013 11:33 AM

Stack some of these to make a 200-400 watt load to replace your speaker load. Be aware they will get warm, at 400 watt load it should not be too bad though.
http://www.parts-express.com/cat/dum...resistors/1535

These could also be used when you are setting bias. A bonus? :)

mystic38 03-08-2013 11:35 AM

well... not to divert you from a full tube amp.. but the GB Streamliner has a 6 stage, three tube preamp with a phenomenal quality DI ..and a free 600 or 900W amp :)

creis2 03-08-2013 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mystic38 (Post 13998754)
well... not to divert you from a full tube amp.. but the GB Streamliner has a 6 stage, three tube preamp with a phenomenal quality DI ..and a free 600 or 900W amp :)

I have the 900, love it.


Not really necessary for me to do this with the 100w tube head, I didn't even buy it yet. I just threw out a hypothetical, just to understand how tube amps work and what their limits are.

B-string 03-08-2013 11:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mystic38 (Post 13998754)
well... not to divert you from a full tube amp.. but the GB Streamliner has a 6 stage, three tube preamp with a phenomenal quality DI ..and a free 600 or 900W amp :)

And the G-K Fusion 550 or MB Fusion have the same with a 500 watt amp and over 800 watt burst power (550 tested at 836). ;)

mystic38 03-08-2013 11:57 AM

agreed..hadnt realised the Fusion 550 was an all tube pre..looks nice so yup call that an option too!.. how is the DI on those things?.. so far the STL has the best DI i have ever (not) heard!

Quote:

Originally Posted by B-string (Post 13998821)
And the G-K Fusion 550 or MB Fusion have the same with a 500 watt amp and over 800 watt burst power (550 tested at 836). ;)


Mark Reccord 03-08-2013 11:59 AM

If the tube amp has a master volume, you can just turn that all the way down and run the preamp out to an external power amp if you're careful to make sure it doesn't get turned up inadvertently.

If the amp has a post-EQ effects send, you can use that to drive the power amp as plugging into it automatically breaks the connection between the preamp and power amp. Once again, you'd have to be careful that it doesn't get unplugged while playing.

Passinwind 03-08-2013 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by creis2 (Post 13998532)
I tried to do some research, but I haven't found anything that helped.

I'm looking at a 100W tube head. It should cover 99% of gigs, but the idea of possibly running the preamp into a high power power amp for trying different setups interests me.

I know a tube amp has to be plugged into a load at all times.

Is there a simple dummy load solution, then use the preamp out into a poweramp?

Or is this just a bad idea all around?

Layman's terms please :D.

If (and only if) your amp has a power amp in jack that cuts preamp signal to the power section:
  • Prepare and insert a shorting plug into the power amp input jack.
  • Insert another shorting plug into the power amp output, or better yet use a dummy load of any wattage you have handy. A 25 watt resistor will only run you a couple of bucks. I have actually just relied on the shorting jack at the output of my power amp section many times, but not all amps have one, and they tend to get dirty and intermittent over the years. You could also just leave a speaker plugged in.
  • Could something still go wrong? Yes, but I have used this method successfully hundreds of times and so have a few of my former customers. As Mark says, always verify that your connections are good.

capcom 03-08-2013 12:03 PM

You can also remove all power tubes if that is a technical possibility for that kind of amp. If it is possible, then you won't damage the amp while an actual speaker load is not connected.

I have 1967 made all tube 50 Watt Fender Bassman head that it also have a line out modification made 15 years ago in order to get the pure preamp sound for either recording or for amplifying with another amp. In this mode I used my amp this way several times without connecting it to a speaker and never had a problem.

50 watt classic Bassman Heads has 2 power tubes and you can also use it with only 1 power tube while connected to a speaker load.
100 Watt Bassman Heads have 4 power tubes and I believe all can be taken out if only its preamp will be used.

However some tube amps may not permit removing all or some of power tubes like Bassman. I guess it was mentioned again before in this forum that For example 300 Watt Ampeg SVT all-tube heads shouldn't be used by removing their power tubes. Need more details about this subject from more knowledgable people.

B-string 03-08-2013 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mystic38 (Post 13998900)
agreed..hadnt realised the Fusion 550 was an all tube pre..looks nice so yup call that an option too!.. how is the DI on those things?.. so far the STL has the best DI i have ever (not) heard!

The DI is excellent, pre or post your choice, adjustable level with ground lift.

Mr. Foxen 03-08-2013 12:09 PM

Cab loud enough to work with 100w is safer option. Or get a valve preamp and a selection of power amps, I used to do that, until I got the loud cab, various valve slave amps to go with a V-type pre.

B-string 03-08-2013 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by capcom (Post 13998943)
You can also remove all power tubes if that is a technical possibility for that kind of amp. If it is possible, then you won't damage the amp while an actual speaker load is not connected.

I have 1967 made all tube 50 Watt Fender Bassman head that it also have a line out modification made 15 years ago in order to get the pure preamp sound for either recording or for amplifying with another amp. In this mode I used my amp this way several times without connecting it to a speaker and never had a problem.

50 watt classic Bassman Heads has 2 power tubes and you can also use it with only 1 power tube while connected to a speaker load.
100 Watt Bassman Heads have 4 power tubes and I believe all can be taken out if only its preamp will be used.

However some tube amps may not permit removing all or some of power tubes like Bassman. I guess it was mentioned again before in this forum that For example 300 Watt Ampeg SVT all-tube heads shouldn't be used by removing their power tubes. Need more details about this subject from more knowledgable people.

I wondered if this would show up. When you pull the output tubes there is a real possibility of the high voltage going way out of spec to the preamp tubes. Don't do this without an experienced tech checking the B+ to the preamp valves.

Passinwind 03-08-2013 12:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. Foxen (Post 13998972)
get a valve preamp and a selection of power amps

+1

If you're only going to use the preamp section of an all-tube amp, just cut to the chase...;) The OP did say he's just looking for a 1% of the time solution though.

taurus1 03-08-2013 02:57 PM

I have a Ho's Electronics Attenuator, as well as a Ho's Electronics dummy load.
the dummy load has a built in variac as well as a variable line out.
I use a 1970 Bassman 50 into the dummy load into an eq and then to the power amp. works really well.
Ho built if for me for $125.00, this was years ago but they probably wouldn't cost a lot more now.
the attenuator can work as a dummy load as well but costs more.

Tuned 03-08-2013 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Reccord (Post 13998914)
If the tube amp has a master volume, you can just turn that all the way down and run the preamp out to an external power amp if you're careful to make sure it doesn't get turned up inadvertently.

Even at idle a tube power amp needs a load or it's bad for the tubes. The simple solution is to pull the power tubes and use the preamp out. Perfectly safe.

ThisBass 03-08-2013 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by creis2 (Post 13998532)
I tried to do some research, but I haven't found anything that helped.

I'm looking at a 100W tube head. It should cover 99% of gigs, but the idea of possibly running the preamp into a high power power amp for trying different setups interests me.

I know a tube amp has to be plugged into a load at all times.

Is there a simple dummy load solution, then use the preamp out into a poweramp?

Or is this just a bad idea all around?

Layman's terms please :D.

I don't know your amp, but most of times it is possible to fix such problems with a shortened plug into power amp in (or plug with same treatment).

ThisBass 03-08-2013 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuned (Post 14000333)
Even at idle a tube power amp needs a load or it's bad for the tubes. The simple solution is to pull the power tubes and use the preamp out. Perfectly safe.

In general the OT (the output plug) is shortened if nothing is plugged into the output plug.

Mark Reccord 03-08-2013 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuned (Post 14000333)
Even at idle a tube power amp needs a load or it's bad for the tubes. The simple solution is to pull the power tubes and use the preamp out. Perfectly safe.

Nah. No signal, no worries. The failure mode of running no load on a transformer coupled amp is related to inductive flyback. No signal no flyback. :)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:14 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.