Different gauges on different basses?

[Bobby King]

Do you folks ever find that even on similar basses, a different gauge string works better than on the other? For instance, I usually use a .105-.045 set on my Fender Jazz, but I have a Fender-style PJ with a Modulus neck, and it always sounded kind of choked and stiff-feeling with that gauge. So I tried .100 -.040 (same brand D'Addario XL nickel), and now the bass really sings. Some of my basses like a .105 E, others like a .100. I actually don't think it's the gauge as much as the tension. Some basses seem to like more, some less. It can make a big difference in how the bass responds.

[eateachother]

Hey Bobby. You're right about the way a lighter or heavier guage set of strings changes the sound. I was told today that I'd need to have my bass set up for a switch of guages. Did you do anything with the intonation, or did it just seem OK? I was also told that heavier strings might do more damage to the neck, perhaps less so if you set it up for the heavier ones. I do not know, and came to post a similar question. But since you went lighter, if it doesn't buzz on you I don't see how that could hurt anything.

[fretlessguy]

Although I nearly got myself in a heated debate over this question, I still believe that different gauges and or string types can bring out the best in a particular bass.
Most basses, if set up properly, can handle a wide range of tensions and gauges. There are some that cannot. The best thing to do, if you are not sure, is to contact the manufacturer of the bass and see.

FG

[andk5591]

I have been playing for almost 40 years. Have owned more basses than I can remember and for the bulk of that time I have had 2 to 5 basses at a time.

If you are really into your instruments and their feel, "one size fits all" is not possible. Even though the bulk of the instruments are mass produced, you have too many variables for the same string to work on all of them. With same brand/model/vintage, its USUALLY not as noticable, but as you have more differences you should find what works the best. Experience will help make this easier. Like right now, my fretless Jazz style has light guage Elixirs rounds, my main bass (P-Bass style) like DR Sunbeam lights, my Gibson EB3L really likes Dean Markley cryo extra Light rounds.

Play the bass without being plugged in and the feel and its natural sound is what you are looking for.

[JazzyLambert]

I have med. 105-45 (DR black beauties) on my old EMG loaded Yammy P-bass, but use superlight. 95-40 (D'addario cheapies) on my Cort Artisan.

Cant Groove @14

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kN9DTrLaqVU

[JustDavid]

If you didn't have the bass set up after the string (tension) change you did in fact change your setup (truss rod at the same tension would give you flatter neck relief), which might be what you noticed.

[knuckle_head]

Originally Posted by andk5591

If you are really into your instruments and their feel, "one size fits all" is not possible.

I agree.

Identically made instruments are never identical.