Impressions (of gut strings)

[olivieraleman]

Hi all
I have spent the better part of 2 years trying different gut, and gut like, strings and I wanted to post my impressions for someone who may be new to the double bass and maybe considering trying gut strings. I will include Eudoxa,Olive, and Velvets even though these are a hybrid string with attributes of steel strings and guts.

G String
Gamut Lyon heavy+
Chorda Carlos
Lenzner
All these sound good on my bass(Upton Hybrid). If I had to choose it would be the Gamut heavy+.
Olive G and Eudoxa G both sound good, however, both came unwound so I wont try them again.

D String
Gamut Lyon heavy+
Artone
Chorda Carlos
Lenzner
Of these the Chorda Carlos is the best on my bass followed by the Gamut. But Im not satisfied with any of them. They are beautiful up to about F#, then, nothing. I am currently using a Eudoxa D with my Chorda Carlos. I have tried the Olive D with plain G and like it too. No unwinding of the Olive or Eudoxa D so far. The Velvet Garbo D and Lite D also blend well.

A String
Chorda Carlos
Fisoma
Lenzner
Pirastro Pizzicato
The Chorda, Fisoma, and Lenzner all sound great. The Pizzicato is to thin and twangy for my taste. I dont like the Eudoxa or Olive for an A string. Garbo and Lite are good too, but Ill take a wound A for mine.

E String
Chorda Carlos
Fisoma
Lenzner
Pirastro Pizzicato
Im not satisfied with any of these, tho the Chorda is the best of the lot. Too many choked notes. The Velvet Anima is the best E string Ive had on my bass. I dont like the Eudoxa, or the Olive. The Pizzicato was clear but too thin. Its at .106 and the Chorda Carlos is at .124. We need something in between for a wound E, say like .110 - .120.

Anyway, there it is. I am using Chorda Carlos with a Eudoxa D and am as satisfied as Ive ever been, both acoustic and amped. With the exception of the Lenzners, all strings were purchased, or traded, used from TB members. Thnx guys, you know who you are. John

[Nathan Parker]

Thanks for posting all that info. I appreciate the time, effort and money it took to give folks such a comprehensive review.

I'm pretty happy with Chorda's, both the regular, and the special gauges. But, I hear you, that D string is a tough one.

[olivieraleman]

Thnx Nathan, I appreciate that. Actually the cost isnt too bad if you get them used and resell or trade if you dont like. Of course all the on/off of different basses is hard on some strings, so Ive ended up eating some, but such is life. John

[Norre]

Hey, thanks for the info
I've never played guts before and lately I've been really intrigued by them. So I decided to order a set of Chorda Carlos Henriquez strings.
Delivery was fast and the customer support at Pirastro is great.
After Pirastro received my money I got the strings within 2 days (last friday).

This is why I like UPS:


I haven't installed them yet (I hope next week).

Anyway, thanks for the review and I hope I'll be as happy as you are with the Chorda CH set. I'm wondering about that D though

[davpal]

My experience with Pirastro Eudoxa so far -
I picked up a set of Eudoxa's from another TB member back in January. He tried them for only about two weeks and couldn't get comfortable with them. Anyway, I put them on as soon as I got them - weather conditions were cold & dry. I wondered if I made a big mistake.... they felt as stiff as Spiro mittels and seemed to have about half the volume of the Velvet Blues I just took off! Well, I wasn't going to give up on them so quickly so I persevered. Really gave my hands a workout though. They were almost impossible to bow, which I found especially frustrating since I found the Velvets to be so easy....very light pressure and a great, full sound.
Well, I'm glad I stuck with it because as the weather has gotten warmer and the humidity is coming up these strings are really starting to work well! They feel much softer under the fingers and the volume has increased noticeably. Arco has become much easier - the harmonics are still not quite as easy as the Velvets but seem to be getting better almost daily. I think the gut core has softened up a lot...If you think of them as being like leather it would make sense that working them a lot would do this. The other issue I've had, as well as people that have posted here, is the sometimes sticky feeling. This comes and goes and I haven't figured it all out yet.... wash my hands, don't wash my hands, wipe the strings down a lot, don't clean them at all? Sometimes the silver is slick as can be... that's what I want all the time!
So, my advice to anyone trying new guts would be to give them time and take weather conditions into consideration before passing judgment - I'm glad I did!

[olivieraleman]

Dave
That sticky feel on the Eudoxa bothered me too. Im with you on giving gut, and gut core, strings time before making any judgements. The Eudoxa D sounded bright next to the Chorda G when I first put it on, but now, two weeks later it has mellowed right in with the set. Funny thing though, when I amplify its the quietest, go figure.


Norre
Good luck with the Carlos, they are fine strings. I hope the D works for you,too. Obviously alot of gut players are happy with a plain D, and I want so bad to be able to use one. Often times Im tempted to put the D back on and be content with only 4 notes! But being able to utilize more notes saves me from shifting as much, which helps my intonation, and I really need help in that area! John

[Norre]

which helps my intonation, and I really need help in that area!

Don't we all ? ... I know I do

[olivieraleman]

Hi all
An update on my gut string quest. Recently got a great deal on near new Clef guts from Roonz (thnx Bobby). Im putting them in the bullpen for now but wanted to post some measurements. G=.084, D=.110, A=.095, E=.115. Taken with a Starrett digital caliper. These strings have loops and do not resemble or mic out at what the Lenzners I had did, to answer a common question. More info forthcoming. John

[olivieraleman]

Hi all, an update
I recently bought a mess of inexpensive guts to see what they were about and here are my impressions. Some of these were on my bass 2 weeks, some only one day and some I bought, measured, inspected and sold before I installed them.

While its true guts need time to settle in, no amount of time will make a poor string good. Now that I have 2 basses I can string one and let it sit while I gig with the other. Here goes:

Artone plain A...this string was old and rough when I got it, but I installed it and gigged twice with it. Though very thumpy, it was warm, fat and loud. It amplified well. Makes me want to try a Pistoy plain A. Should be the ticket for backing up singers.

Clef with wound A and E...the D and G are good, the A and E are thin in gauge and look to be wound with iron! Overall this is not a bad set if you wanna try guts without spending the bread on Gamuts/Dlugolecki. The D is one of the better Ive tried, but bassists at gigs said the E didn't carry. G.084, D.106, A.095, E.115

Boothill G,D, and plain A...bought but never tried. G.087, D.109, A.120 which is what my Pistoy D measures. These have that opaque look...like the following...though darker..

Global/Emerson plain E and A....these also have that look and some claim are beef gut. I didnt leave them on long, and had to pull the E through the tuner with pliers. There was just enough sound with the E to make you wonder what a quality plain E would sound like, though it would probably cost 300.00!

LaBella wound E...this one has the ball and felt washer, not the loop like some I have seen. Measures.136 and reminds me 0f the Lenzner E. Not as defined as the Gamut or Chorda Carlos but not bad.

I started on guts 35 years ago and still prefer them. Anyone who wants to give guts a try, I'll be happy to help. John