I've A/B'd them on basses and found the aluminum gave the "vintage" tone well and the brass was "modern".
The functional aspect was that the aluminum had a more muffled, subdued tone that would be ideal for, say, classic rock, motown, reggae.
The brass was in your face with sustain for days. Great for metal, funk, punk, or that crystal-clear smooth jazz stuff.
__________________ Please check out my band, JUPITER HORSE on Facebook and Reverbnation 50+ Basses Club #49 - Sold my car, Bought a bass Club #12 - Ohio Bassist #211 - Status Reg. #7