Quote:
Originally Posted by Munjibunga  Sounds good, but I think a string pad would help, and a little less pounding out quarter notes on the piano. |
Yeah I agree with that, but I really didn't have much of a say with that at all, as a matter of fact I hadn't heard anything besides a scratch piano part until a few days ago(and it was recorded over the summer)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lowtonejoe The drums come in rough.
The kick sounds terrible for this song.
Way too heavy on the compressor. (A conversion artifact maybe?)
And yeah, the quarter notes on the piano are a bit excessive.
The rest of it sounds really really good.
I liked the bassline and the vocals. The piano sounded good (except the quarter note thing) and the chimes were a nice effect.
All in all I would give this a thumbs up. 
Joe. |
Yeah the guy had a really crappy drumset, and his mixing didn't make them sound any better, but thanks for the kind words, it was something fairly different than what I usually do so it was a good experience.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DWBass +1
The mix is not a good one. The drums should be really soft (I would have used a percussionist). I didn't like that pattern the drummer was using either! As for the bass playing, I honestly think it's way too busy. A song like that should be about the vocalist. Stick with the roots and play simple for a song like that. There's a place for creative playing and a place to lay back and let the song flow. One last thing, the drummer and bassist should always work together to define a solid backbone to any song. It sounded, to me, like you guys were on different pages. Just my opinion. |
I agree for the most part with what you said, as I said before, I also hate the mixing on the drums. I could go either way on what he is playing, but I never even played the song live with the drummer. The whole process of how the guy recorded it was kind of whacked, and it could definantly be improved on, and I'm hoping he learned that from us. All I played to was a scratch piano track and her vocals. There were a few takes that I played a lot mellower, but she liked it when I played like that (it was her song so I better do what she says!) I think there were parts in my line that could be changed for the better, but the first time I saw the chart was the first take so I think it went well for that.
Thanks for all the kind words and input guys.
