I play bass and sing(yell) in a heavy sludge metal rock band. We're a trio. We went to the studio and recorded our EP in 2011 www.burrowsmusic.bandcamp.com
released it ourselves as a free download. We were very happy with it and still push it. Excellent use of time and money. Since then we've been playing shows, we had a couple line-up changes, and are now aiming to record again.
Our current guitarist has some good experience with recording and the software, we have enough equipment and software to record it ourselves. We want this to sound good, but we also want to learn from it as well. BUT the guitarist and drummer want to record this all live in our rehearsal space; in the same room, mics on the drums and all our amps, and either record the vocals separately OR run a lineout from our PA to the interface and record everything together. Of course there will be some bleed over, but we attempted this lastnight and it sounded pretty good and very little bleed. I don't have much experience recording things myself, other than having recorded 3 albums in studios with a producer at the board. I, personally, think that if we're going to put the time and effort into a recording then we should record in the traditional sense of recording each element separately; I've rationalized everything that this would be more efficient, but my two bandmates are still wanting to record everything live. I can't possibly imagine how a live recording would sound as good or better than a track by track recording. I go with the flow and in this bands almost 4 year existence, we've had zero problems and drama and I consider these guys close friends and it's the most awesome/rewarding/fun band I've ever been in and I'm proud of that and appreciate it, but I just can't understand how/why anyone would do a live recording when there is all the capability and means to do a higherquality studio recording ourselves. I've always been a perfectionist when it comes to recording, especially if it's something that we plan on releasing. I'd rather spend the time writing a few more songs then record, than do this work for a live recording that I can't see sounding as good; For example, "oh dag my distortion was too loud/not loud enough on that part", that means we'd have to do it all over again, rather than just me re-doing that section.
What should I do? Am I wrong in feeling this way? If so, how can I convince them? what are the pros/cons of each method? it just seems like a waste of time to do a live recording when doing our own studio recording ourselves would be much better quality and take not much more time to do. Thank you for reading. I appreciate any/all responses.