Ditch the BBE ASAP, and if the compressor isn't "doing" anything to help you, ditch that too.
I bought a BBE as it sounded GREAT in the music store when I demo'd it. Unfortunately, what I didn't realize is that the "on" switch activates inherent scoopiness that can simply suck the tone out of a quality bass and preamp. Not to discount its ability in certain situations or in a studio application, but after a while I realized that it just didn't make a positive contribution to my live setup. The only reason to keep it was the flashing lights, and even that wasn't enough.
Compressors can definitely be useful to even out peaks and valleys in your playing, but it sounds like you've got your stuff together enough where a comp is just going to be another set of knobs to tweak when you could just be playing and enjoying yourself.
Simpler IS better. Part of the reason why I love my Alembic F-1x preamp so much...three knobs, two switches, yay!
Lonnybass