Can a pick sound like fingers?

[Munjibunga]

Rubber or felt. Give it a try.

[PBass101]

Dunlop purple's sound alot less like a pick than any other pick I've used, hardly any of the 'snap' or twang that most picks give you, just as long as you aren't hitting the strings as hard as you possibly can.

[TL5]

+1 to felt

[ugly_bassplayer]

No.