Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tim99 I agree that TAB on the internet is crap because most is wrong, but your point that TAB is crap because it does not contain rhythm is bogus. No one I know uses TAB without having the CD handy. Both TAB and standard music notation can not begin to pick up the actual feel of the music. So if you use TAB or standard musical notation, you still need to listen to and play along with the CD. |
I get your point, and personally I always prefer to hear music if I'm going to play it, because I dont read well at all, but I still believe tab is rubbish. If you are starting out you are far better off learning by ear and/or using notation.
It is completely possible to interpret and perform a piece from music from a sheet with no recordings to go from. You cannot do that from tab, at all.
G---------
D---------
A---------
E-0-0-0-0-
Is that four crochets? Two quavers, a crochet and a minim? Tab is not even a notation, it's a diagram of 'where to put your fingers'.
Of course the dots are only an approximation of the feel of any piece of music, just as words are on a page, but in the same way as you interpret the words on a page to mean something to you, you do the same with written music.
I'm learning to read music now, slowly, and most of what I learn is the melodies to jazz tunes. I think this a perfect example, the notation doesnt detail swing, I have to interpret it, but at least the placement of the notes in bar is given
Tb s lk wrtng wtht ny vwls r pncttn sm wds cnt b rd s esly