I just order the Tuff-Bag. I based this on the specs listed vs. cost. The 3-year warranty is important to me.
I previously had a TKL bag which: 1) zippers broke in one year, 2) the pockets ripped, and most importantly, 3) the strap "D" rings tore loose. I threw that bag in the trash where it belonged. (wouldn't even consider giving that death-trap away to my worst enemy)

I've put WAY too much $$$ into my URB to have it be dumped on the street because of a cheap bag.
If I got any issues with the new Tuff-Bag I report 'em right here. Signing off....