Quote:
Originally posted by Bill Brasky Why is transcribing a controversial topic lately? I haven't been looking around here very much recently but I'd be interested to read about what other people's thoughts are about it. |
In "Miscellaneous" there's a recent thread about transcribing bass lines.
Quote:
| I can only really do that for the melody. I don't think I could pick out all the chord changes for most jazz tunes by ear. |
Then, my friend, IMO the work you put in on it would be at least as valuable as the work you put in learning standards from charts. One thing all the "Miscellaneous" posters agree on is that developing your ear is critical to improving musicianship in jazz.
Start with a modal tune without tons of changes. Listen to root-motion -- easy for bassist, eh? Then try to hear major/minor/diminished. Then maybe upper partials. THEN, if you can find a chart, you can see how you did!
Hope this helps.