I have to agree with PCBH's sentiment here.
JWC: that is far too dismissive of what is one of the most popular genres in the world.
Also, the fact the rap is a vocal technique and that Hip-Hop is a style shows how little you know about it.
Rapping as a technique can be so varied. Lauryn Hill raps softly, NWA rap hard, De La Soul rap mellow and funky... It also involves an amazing amount of vocal dexterity. Free-rapping (rapping without pre-written lyrics) is one of the most amazing things I've ever heard - it's like a free jazz solo, but with rhyme and meaning- top make up rhymes in rhythm and expression/intonation on the spot takes a great deal of skill. Ella Fitzgerald sung whole songs of scat, does that come under the rap umberella and is that 'crap' as well?
Before critisising further check out the UK Hip-Hop scene.
Go and get hold of a copy of "The Herbaliser - Very Mercenary". You can buy it online at
http://www.ninjatune.com - DONT get anything from Napster as ninja tune are a small independant label and need all the money they can get.
The Herbaliser are mainly two guys, but they recruit some of the UKs best musicians and play a straight instrumental jazz/hip-hop/dance/break-beat set that would bring tears to your eyes... I saw them once in London and I can only compair the IMMENSE vibe to that of James Browns stuff in the late 60's.
"I wish the noise known as rap would vanish from this planet."
To quote the great(?) Eminem "I dont give a s**t if you dont like my s**t, casue I was high when I wriote this so suck my d**k". I dont mean this personally, just a joke.
"I hate rap with a passion. It is the most disturbing, annoying, crap I have ever heard."
OK then, The Beatles were great I agree, but what about Frog Chorus by Mr McCartney?
"Hey, I play hard music too, but my way of getting out is putting on some Beatles or Moody Blues, not making a rap album."
Hey I'm not capable of critisising The Beatles, but Hard??? I think not!
"God save music."
...from what? Progression? Saints preserve us!
[Edited by arther daily on 01-29-2001 at 09:36 AM]