Prog Wars : which bass player ?

[speak2planets]

Okay, I know its not technically prog but when it comes to 70's technical, worked out music I always go for my Zappa collection. I know he used a few different bassists during the 70's but if you listen to something like "Waka/Jawaka" or "Roxy & Elsewhere" you get the same complexity of prog rock that you get from Yes or King Crimson. But as far as bassists from that era, hands down Squire is the man.

[pbass2]

Squire is #1 for me too, followed by the usual suspects--Wetton, Lake, etc. (and I'm happy to say I saw most all of them in concert multiple times) but I'm really happy to see some of the others mentioned here--Gentle Giant, Flash, Strawbs, Wishbone Ash, etc. Man, it's all the music of my youth--takes me back.....

[Belar2001]

Dave Pegg with Fairport Convention and Jethro Tull excellent player. Of course Wetton, Levin, Lee, Squire, what about John Paul Jones? He is pretty progressive, guess it depends on the definition.

[Don Tony]

Originally Posted by smcgov

you should check the latest Transatlantic release, pete trewavas' tone on this CD is to my ears a top 5 ever bass tone on a recording and it melds perfectly with Pourtnoy's drum sound.

I've always loved Rush but the older I get I appreciate Chris Squire maybe a little more.

Mike Rutherford is pretty awesome, try to pick out the bass line from Behind The Lines off Duke....

not sure of their names but the bass players from Spock's Beard and the Flower Kings are hot stuff too.

Spock's Beard/Dave Meros The Flower Kings/Jonas Reingold. I gave a bump to Jonas earlier on this thread. Both are Outstanding players. Colin Edwin From Porcupine Tree also outstanding.

[Basshappi]

Make Prog Not War.
Can't I just like them all?

[ooktar]

Originally Posted by speak2planets

Okay, I know its not technically prog but when it comes to 70's technical, worked out music I always go for my Zappa collection. I know he used a few different bassists during the 70's but if you listen to something like "Waka/Jawaka" or "Roxy & Elsewhere" you get the same complexity of prog rock that you get from Yes or King Crimson. But as far as bassists from that era, hands down Squire is the man.

+1

The bass throughout "Joe's Garage" is some of the best bass work I've heard in my opinion.

[sven kalmar]

not to mention the drumming...

[beggar98]

For me, it's Geddy. Had the chops and tone, but grooved harder than just about anyone else being mentioned. There's just enough JPJ in his playing that, even when Rush are way out on the prog ledge, it never sounds cold or sterile.

[Greevus]

All the King Crimson guys: Wetton, Lake, Levin

[Rev J]

Originally Posted by zon6c-f

What ?? No love for Martin Turner of Wishbone Ash??

Turner sings like a bird; 1st Tenor.

Nice British Prog Bass Tone; Used Ricks and T-Birds.

Acoustic and Orange Amps.

And yeah, I enjoy listening to top 10 1970's prog bassists listed in this thread, too.

And what about the fine list of bass players in Jethro Tull? ok..we love em all, which is why we love prog.

I don't have much knowledge of more contemporary prog bands , but OP wanted feedback on 70's prog bassists..so...I gave my 2 cents..

In the more modern updates of classic groups I'd put Steve Bailey with Jethro Tull (I'm a bit biased since I play a Steve Bailey Jazz Bass). Or Kai Eckhardt with Gong (another biased opinion since I took bass lessons from him for a couple of months).

C/S,
Rev J

[Emilym80]

Geddy!

[Roscoe East]

Originally Posted by Rev J

Kai Eckhardt with Gong

Wow, never knew Kai played with Gong... when was that? (After Hansford Rowe, presumably?)

[Rev J]

Originally Posted by Roscoe East

Wow, never knew Kai played with Gong... when was that? (After Hansford Rowe, presumably?)

My bad it was Gongzilla:

http://t-rex-effects.com/artists-1/a...ngzilla-1.aspx

C/S,
Rev J

[jim777]

Chris Squire, Geddy Lee, and Andy West. Maybe The Dixie Dregs weren't strictly prog but Andy West is an absolute monster, no question.

[the_hook]

Geddy Lee #1, after that it's:

Chris Squire - all the early Yes material.
Tony Levin - first heard him on Peter Gabriel's Security, love his other work.
John Wetton - killer bass riffing on King Crimson's Red album on the song 'Providence'
Nick Beggs - killer bass work on Steven Wilson's new Prog album The Raven That Refused to Sing, first track 'Luminol' had me hooked.

[rtav]

Chris Squire - he's amazing... just play "Sound Chaser"... whew
John Myung - 'nuff sed
Geddy - still the best bass tone I've ever heard (Moving Pictures)
Tony Levin - King Crimson, LTE, Peter Gabriel
Greg Lake - Karn Evil 9 2nd Impression; Tarkus
Bryan Beller - incredible

[WalWarrior]

Originally Posted by jgroh

Gary Weinrib

When Gary Weinrib wears condoms, he uses the ones "ribbed" on the inside, for HIS pleasure.

- The Most Interesting Man in the World

[JimmyM]

Originally Posted by WalWarrior

When Gary Weinrib wears condoms, he uses the ones "ribbed" on the inside, for HIS pleasure.

- The Most Interesting Man in the World

Somewhere there's a joke in there, but danged if I can find it!

[Lee H]

geddy rocks it. Of that there is no doubt

but for Prog, I an a big fan of the old Royal Hunt stuff
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WdasU6M4LQ0




mostly because John West is a good friend of mine...but I am allowed to be biased when it comes to friends with vocals like that..

[Musiclogic]

I am having a hard time believing in all these examples that nobody has mentioned the ever present "Hawkwind" and the bass playing of Lemmy......c'mon guys.....LMAO

I just could not help tossing this in.....

As a side note, Geddy, Chris Squire, and Pete Trewavas are 3 of my all time faves, my 3 favorite bands.