5 or 6 strings? Oh, no!

[moopants]

It might just be my opinion, but I think a 5 string bass isn't worth it. I shall explain myself. On a 4 string, you can tune down to D and even C (but it sounds pretty muddy). So, with the extra low B of a 5 string, you're only getting a few extra notes. But, with the 5th string, you don't have to tune down at all, making for better and lower bass lines. With that in mind, why not add a higher string? You can also make better solo lines and faster and easier runs with the C string. One example, if you've ever played the Overture of Russlan and Ludmilla on electric bass, instead of moving up and down the G string, you can stay in typically one position with the use of a C string. Any opinions or arguments are welcome. I'm curious to see what other bassists have to say about it.

[Poop-Loops]

Why not just get a 5 string with a low B and play in 5th position if you need that high C?

I mean, how often do bass player go beyond the 12 fret anyway? So you're not losing anything anyway.

[Dave]

Thats the same idea with a 5 string. I find that I use the low B more for keeping on the same place of the neck instead of having those extra notes, though I do use them from time to time.

[ras1983]

go to the basses forum, post this exact same thread.

someone will tell its been discussed to death, and will ask you to use the search function.

you will use the search function.

cheers.

[tplyons]

I use a four because it's more comfortable to me. Though I sometimes wish that I had a five so I didn't have to move quite so much.

[vindy500]

because 6's either have really big necks or really tight string spacing?

[Pacman]

Done to death, and a pretty stupid topic anyway.