For me, it depends on the band. When I was playing in a top 40 band years ago, the songs didn't have to be perfect. Now playing in my second Allman Bros. tribute band, we're all OCD, I would say.
Thanks for the big laughs in many of these posts, by the way.
Genz Benz Club#387, The Ibanez Club#975, Gallien Kreuger Official Club#880, California Bassists Club#95, Bass Players Tennis Club#1, Flatwounds Club #4, Danelectro Owners Club#38