Can you enjoy music as a non musician would ?

[fearceol]

I am just wondering how pro musicians view (hear) music casually ? What I mean is, if they go to a gig or concert to see their favourite band or artist, do they leave their musician's hat at the door and simply enjoy the music for what it is. Or are they constantly analysing the theory behind the music as it is happening.

I am far from being a pro musician. I have a basic knowledge of theory, and play bass for the sheer enjoyment of it. Granted, as a bassist myself, my attention will be on that musician in the band, to see what technique he uses etc, but generally I will enjoy the music as music, not as say a II V I etc.

The way I see it is, that music is meant to be enjoyed. It can console us when we are sad and enhance our happiness. While it is great to know the nuts and bolts of how music is made, and how to make our own, I think people are missing out on a lot of enjoyment, if they constantly "have their head under the hood, and don't stand back now and then to admire the nice shiny car".


I am not saying that people actually do this. I am simply curious, and would welcome people's views and opinions.

[cnltb]

Can you enjoy music as a non musician would ?


These days I can.

[SolarMan]

I know what you mean - analyzing the song instead of just enjoying it.

I do think that "knowing" too much can get in the way.

And, I (like many here, I'm sure) focus first on the bass. You know, the part that "regular" people don't even hear.

But, when a song is good - you will know "why" it is good, and maybe even enjoy it MORE than regular folk.

Double edge IMO

[MrMeacham]

How would I know?

[fdeck]

We live in an anti-intellectual society.

Can a physicist enjoy a starry night? Can a biologist fall in love? There's a tacit assumption that too much learning spoils the fun, and that a non-intellectual experience is somehow more authentic.

But it's just an assumption. There's no reason to think that learning spoils pleasure. In fact, learning is a source of pleasure in and of itself.

[ggunn]

Years ago I read an article in Scientific American on this subject. They were able to determine that the activity in a musician's brain while listening to music was in a different area from that of a non musician. It was in a region associated with analytical processing, while the activity in a non musician's brain was in an different area.

[Tituscrow]

If you can't paint or act, can you appreciate a painting or enjoy a film?

[Melonthief]

Interesting post. I am able to listen to a song as a "fan" and be transported. When I sit down to learn the same song some of the magic goes away. Instead of being a complete piece it is now a series of notes, chords, fretboard positions etc.
BUT when it comes time to perform it in a band situation it becomes magic again.

[SunnBass]

Being a musician keeps me from liking crappy music.

[TigerInATrance]

Originally Posted by SunnBass

Being a musician keeps me from liking crappy music.

Indeed... In fact, I might enjoy some of the more "fun" stuff out there if I could get past the fact that it's incredibly bad music.

The music I do enjoy, though, I like because I can go very deep into it and know what they're doing. I can pick out subtle things that just fly by others.

I cannot, however, turn it off and be like one of the unwashed rabble who just like a catchy hook and a pretty face...

[Casting Thunder]

I've found the deeper I get into playing bass the more I dissect music I don't like, so now I have a more educated opinion on why I don't like that song/band.

[Nev375]

Can you enjoy it? Yes
Without analyzing it? Yes
The same way a non-musician would? No

Once you have traded your ignorance for knowledge in a certain field, you have permanently altered your point of view.

... Unless you are a musical savant of some sort, then maybe

[JoeVictim]

Originally Posted by SunnBass

Being a musician keeps me from liking crappy music.

+1

Music is emotion for me. It allows so much more than a regular listener.

[FrednBass]

Originally Posted by MrMeacham

How would I know?

this

[cricman]

Originally Posted by SunnBass

Being a musician keeps me from liking crappy music.

Unfortunately, being a musician hasn't stopped me from listening to and often liking "crappy" music. Sometimes art is a beautiful symphony, a trumpet sonata, or a well executed bass line. Sometimes it is a vulgar, visceral, and chaotic sonic melee. Sometimes, it's just a catchy hook from a crappy top 40 song (especially from the 1970s.) All examples fully capable of expressing and evoking thought and emotion. Admit it, we all have our secret guilty pleasures!


cricman

[Roaddog77]

I watch and listen to the bass player more than anyone else in a band too. I do find myself analyzing the music a lot but not all the time. If a band is particularly good and I'm enjoying myself with my family or some friends it's easy to just have fun and not analyze it. On the other hand if a song is terrible or the band or one of the members is sloppy or bad it's hard not to analyze things.

I really enjoy watching a band I used to be with and I find myself analyzing their new bass players take on the songs. I find it almost impossible not to analyze the bass when a band plays a song I know or have played. I can enjoy music as much as any non musician and when it's good or bad I may know a little more about why.

[GrayHatBass]

Before I picked up bass, I used to listen to a lot of pop music from the 2000s. After teaching myself and getting music lessons, my tastes expanded and I wanted complex music to satisfy the knowledge that I acquired.

[spade2you]

Originally Posted by SunnBass

Being a musician keeps me from liking crappy music.

I think all people can connect songs and the human experience. Being a musician makes us a bit of a tougher crowd to please. Ya hate to pull the snob card, but at a certain point, some music can be painful.

[pbass6811]

Originally Posted by Tituscrow

If you can't paint or act, can you appreciate a painting or enjoy a film?

Did you kind of miss the point? If you COULD paint, would would you be able to look at a painting and just enjoy its beauty/style, like a non-artist, or would you just look at the technique used or the use of colors or shading or whatever? If you COULD act, would you just be able to enjoy a movie, like a non-artist, or would you just analyze the actors performances, or the cinematography, or the musical score?

Originally Posted by Nev375

Can you enjoy it? Yes
Without analyzing it? Yes
The same way a non-musician would? No

Once you have traded your ignorance for knowledge in a certain field, you have permanently altered your point of view.

... Unless you are a musical savant of some sort, then maybe

This I agree with.

I love to listen to music as a "fan". I know what I like and what I think is "good'' and not so much. Having said that, my wife and I like most of the same music, but usually for different reasons. I may think a song is great because it has a pleasing(to me)chord progression or, obviously, a great bass line, or just a killer groove. My wife, on the other hand, may like the same song because she likes the singers voice or the lyrics(she is starting to develop her own ideas as to what a "cool" bass line is, so that's pretty sweet...!). We both listen to the same song...We both LIKE the same song...We like the song for different reasons.

[Astreaux]

Originally Posted by Nev375

Can you enjoy it? Yes
Without analyzing it? Yes
The same way a non-musician would? No

Once you have traded your ignorance for knowledge in a certain field, you have permanently altered your point of view.

+1 ^^^ This