Ahh, nevermind.
I'm going to update this for archival purposes.
So through a random encounter at a Sam Ash in Queens, I actually got to talk to Jerry Brooks himself who was unfortunately off for the night. (Super nice guy!
Incredible player, too.)
His recommendations were:
The Village Underground, 130 W 3rd St
Groove, 125 Macdougal St
Cafe Wha, 115 Macdougal St
Lion's Den, 214 Sullivan St
all of which are conveniently located in Greenwich Village, right next to the NYU campus.