The total speaker area is more important than the power rating of the amp.
Two amps with the same speaker sizes and power rating aren't necessarily equally loud.
I had a 400 watt Hughes & Kettner Quantum combo with 2 x 10" speakers. It was never loud enough for me. My current amp (Yamaha BBT500H) pumps out 250 watts with one 4 ohm cabinet and 500 watts with two cabinets (2 ohms). Even the configuration amp + a 210 speaker is louder than the H&K combo and if I use the 410 instead it's already much louder. But the loudest configuration is of course to use both cabs and all 500 watts available. I always use this config on rock gigs.
The difference in loudness between the two amps is that the Yamaha system don't waste power on the lowest frequencies (<50-60 Hz), at least not with the 10" speakers I own, like the H&K did. I can get those lowest frequencies from the PA subwoofers instead.