Count me among the many techs who don't have much faith in cleaner spray stuff in getting rid of gritty contact noise. Sometimes it works, but usually not for long.
I recently found a long-lost c.1968 Italian Crybaby that had been accidentally stored in incredibly awful circumstances. I plugged it in and the pot noise sounded like the end of the world.
I removed the pot and very carefully disassembled it and cleaned the wafer and wiper, figuring I had nothing to lose. Upon reassembly and reinstallation, the pot worked
perfectly and totally noise-free. In the case of unusual or expensive pots that are make replacement too difficult or pricey, a judicious disassembly and cleaning may save the day.