I don't have a Phatbass, but my EBS Valvedrive is sort of similar. I can tell you that after
extensive auditioning of about a dozen 12ax7/ECC-83/7025 etc. varieties, I found the new Tung-Sol 12ax7 to be the fullest & fattest tube in current production (to
my ears and in
my pedal).
If you're looking for less drive (distortion) you might want to consider an old RCA 7025 (it will have less output & gain, but a nice "depth"). Perhaps a Groove Tubes 12ax7c, for less edginess, would work as well. 12at7's (not a
u7's!)are a lower-gain option that should work as well.
Most TB'ers seem to be JJ devotees, so perhaps JJ has an option as well. I've never tried JJ tubes, but the guy who sells them sure swears by them!
