Quote:
Originally Posted by seamonkey |
Yeah, I looked for this exact thing about 12 months ago, and came to the conclusion that there are only like 2 products on the market which can produce a passable trumpet, for instance. The SampleModeling.com Trumpet was one of the two. The other I can't remember right now, but was significantly more expensive anyway.
Regardless, both of them only worked well if you are a good MIDI wind controller operator, which I am not. I purchased an Akai wind controller just to try out the Garritan software synths, and I am just not skilled enough with the wind controller to produce anything passable. But it's possible, as my friend is a saxophone player and he was able to get an "OK" sounding trumpet out of the Garritan software when we set the Akai up to use saxophone fingering. But it still sounded artificial... not as good as the SampleModeling demo. I never dropped the $175 on the SampleModeling trumpet to see whether it would sound much better...
For the fun of it, I also tried just playing the Garritan trumpet using a MIDI keyboard, and it sounded positively awful. The problem is that you have to be able to modulate the volume (breath) somehow while at the same time bending pitch on note arrival and departure, all while playing the correct notes. I found that I am not skilled enough to do this with a keyboard...