I have done a blonde finish on alder with oil finish over dye. I’ll let you be the judge of how close it is to butterscotch. Maybe not to everyone’s definition. You certainly can’t fog it up. just choosing wood without pronounced grain will help keep a homogenized color without grain popping.
Heres how it came out
.

.
Heres how it got there.
.

.
It has been recommended to me, that to dye Alder, a conditioning coat should be used to better to control the speed and depth of color absorption. The reason is because using dye on woods like alder and birch can cause the final job to appear splotchy.
For my purposes a conditioning coat is just my final finish thinned 50/50 with mineral spirits. I have worked on mostly gun stocks and found some products I really like. Behr’s Scandinavian Tung Oil Finish (TOF) is one of them. It is an easy to work with, flat drying oil with some driers in it. No varnish in it to my knowledge and I have asked around. I have always stayed away from Birch-Casey Tru-Oil on rifle stocks. Not just because of the “metal” spelling but on the advice of cabinet makers and gunsmiths I respect. I’m happy to say that while I think it will protect the neck nicely I don’t think it will work, thinned, as a conditioning coat. Working with it felt like working with polyurethane. It may have “polymerizing oils” in it. I’ll bet that’s code for polyurethane or varnish. It just did not have the work time that oil does, Tung or Boiled Linseed (BLO ).
In goes the 50/50 conditioning.
.

.
Let it dry for a couple of days and in goes the dye ( Trans-tint vintage amber thinned in denatured alcohol)
.

.

.

.
It does look a little splotchy but I think after I build and oil finish it will mellow out a lot.
It might never pass for butterscotch but I like an oil finish so this is the way I went.
Application of Behr’s Scandinavian Tung Oil Finish (TOF).
.

.

.
Applied with poly dauber. Let soak for 25 or so mins. Wipe off with soft cloth. Let cure for at least 24 hours. Repeat as necessary to build finish to taste. In this case 7 or 8 times. Top it off with Johnsons paste wax.
.

.

.
JR