Is this a fair trade?

[pcollin]

This weekend I was hanging with some bass players, assorted musicians, etc., we jammed, had a few laughs etc. One of the guys really liked my 2010 G&L SB-2. It's black with a gun oil maple neck/fingerboard. He offered me a choice in a straight up trade - a 2010 American Olympic White P-bass or his 2011 candy cola American P-bass. both have maple necks/fingerboard and are like new! I was very tempted but said I wanted to think about it. No, alcohol was not involved. I'd like to hear from the court of public opinion. Your thoughts? Thanks!

[GBBSbassist]

I'd go for it. The Candy Cola finish looks amazing.

[SubSectorSucker]

The Fenders will have better resale value if that's what you mean

[Bongolation]

The Candy Cola ones were dumped hard at least twice for some mysterious reason, like half+ off. Like that gray pearl, they once went for $499 at GC on a holiday sale.

Every time I see one, I know there goes a fellow bargain-hunter.

A white Precision in good shape you can sell anywhere, any time. The classic bass.

[mmbongo]

There's a reason why he liked your bass better than either one he has.....

[worxforme]

Keep the G&L

[GM60466]

Keep the G&L