The tuxedo, black on white look just wasn't working for me. I search around for what PG might fit, and most said the MIM 5 string "should" fit. Not finding what I wanted from Fender, I rolled the dice and ordered up a pick guard from Warmoth.
It arrived yesterday and I finally got around to putting it on today. The fit is "okay." The holes pretty much line up (with the major exception being on the lower side, next to the neck - it still went in, but at an angle), the pickup route is a little large (but hidden by the fact the bass is black), and it doesn't quite meet up with the control plate.
Overall, I'm okay with this. From a distance it looks just fine, and this isn't my main bass or an expensive bass. I'll take a few gaps over a plain jane look any day.