1. Welcome to the premier online community and classifieds for bass players!

    Register a free account to post, remove lots of ads, and more!

Lakland Skyline DJ-4 or 44-AJ, Carvin SB4001 or Fender Jazz?

Discussion in 'Basses [BG]' started by Mike Sorr, Feb 15, 2014.


  1. Mike Sorr

    Mike Sorr Play I some music... Supporting Member

    Oct 24, 2012
    Exit 82, NJ
    I'm soon to be in the market for a new Jazz style bass and I've whittled it down to several in the same ballpark price range (give or take a few hundred):

    Lakland Skyline DJ-4 or 44-AJ
    Carvin SB 4000 or 4001
    Fender American Special or American Standard Jazz

    Anyone care to push me in one direction or another?
     
  2. JaredBT

    JaredBT

    Aug 7, 2012
    Clearly the Carvin shines in this bunch. Been playin since '93 (which doesn't mean much actually when people say that) except for a little experience. Lost everything in 2009 and had to sell all my gear, amongst it my main bass was a Stingray 5. Began rebuilding three years ago... 13 instruments later consisting of US & MIJ P's, US & MIJ Jazz's, US G & L's, Ibanez Prestiges, EB MM Sting Rays & Sterlings, slick lawsuit era copy's. I have 4 basses: a Carvin SB 5001, a Carvin PB 5, a Stingray 5 and a Super Cool Ibanez TR5 Expressionist. The only additions will ever be Carvins. The craftsmanship is superb, the necks are THE most comfortable - playable - quick Ive ever played and the sound is... Im sure you can guess my comment. They are truly great instruments, sadly my Stingray 5 never gets played. Anything close to Carvin quality is twice the price. The amps are really good also, great sound and reliability. I would include photos but Im too dumb to figure out how to attach them.
     
  3. wvbass

    wvbass Supporting Member

    Mar 1, 2004
    I wouldn't push you in any direction from there. I have a 44-60, SB5000, and 1998 American Standard Jazz. All are great.

    44-60: Easily the best player of the bunch. Tonally, not so much - at least for me. I pulled the stock pickups in favor of EMG JAX. (If you like a passive tone, you'll love the JAX.) After that, I put Thunderbuckers in it.

    SB5000: Great tone, excellent player. It does not have the magic fretwork of the Lakland.

    1998 Jazz: A workhorse. I played it with no mods as my main player for several years. It is the bass that made me quit being a P bass guy. Great player, great passive tone.

    Fit and finish are very good on all three - I don't see a clear winner in a side by side comparison. Neck profiles are all a little different, but all are great players. I can't rank one ahead of another.
     
  4. Mike Sorr

    Mike Sorr Play I some music... Supporting Member

    Oct 24, 2012
    Exit 82, NJ
    I love the neck on the American Special Jazz basses...the Greasebucket tone pot, not so much. I also like the necks on the Geddy Jazz basses, but I owned one of the black MIJs and and played others and they all sounded thin to my ears. I too am currently a P Bass guy and have a heavily modified American Special, which has the best neck of any P bass I've ever played, by the way. But I find myself jonzin' for a Jazz style bass. I miss that Jazz growl.

    Which of the ones I mentioned has the thinnest neck profile. I've heard really good things about the Carvins. I may have a line on a used B40 which just might take care of everything, and at half the price...if I get it.
     
  5. Sponsored by:

  6. AngelCrusher

    AngelCrusher

    Sep 12, 2004
    Disclosures:
    Mesa Boogie, Tech 21, Taylor, Lakland
    Tough call, but I would go (and did go) Lakland. I chose between all these different basses as well plus a sadowsky.
     
  7. Mike Sorr

    Mike Sorr Play I some music... Supporting Member

    Oct 24, 2012
    Exit 82, NJ
    How much difference is their between the Lakland US Series and the Skylines, I mean aside from the stacks of extra cash a US a Series will set you back? Are the US basses that far superior to the Skylines? My max is about $1300, and preferably less.