Hey all, I just bought a 1976 Fender P bass through Reverb ... got here yesterday. Brought it to band practice last night and unfortunately the D string would not hold it's tuning ... I want to go ahead and replace all the tuning machines since they are pretty beat up anyway. Question, should I be looking for a specific configuration (hole sizing) as to not have to do any drilling or will any Fender brand P bass tuners fit? Sorry if that's a silly question but I've never replaced tuners? Thanks!
You need 4 on a side tuners with 11/16 hole size. Schaller, Gotoh, Wilkenson, Grovers, Fender all good Here is a link to schallers
These look like they'll do the trick: https://www.angela.com/fenderpurevintage70sjazzbasstuners1set.aspx To be honest, I don't know how one of those tuners could slip - are you sure there isn't something else going on?
Ditto on the slipping. Very rare. Fender stock tuners are bulletproof. I'd check to see if the string is verrrrrry slowly slipping out of the center of the post.
Thanks, but I'm pretty sure I'm going to keep it.... That pic was from the day I brought it home - I've since cleaned it up a bit... I bought original period covers and bridge for it, and put it back to "right" - this is what it looks like now:
Are you really sure the E tuner is not holding? My 75P has so much space with the E tuner you can put a toothpick next to it in the tunerpeg shaft. It is still holding.
Yup, It was the string, I just went and took a look and the string pulled out of the hole post. Thanks for the advice ... man do I feel stupid right now
Naw, nothing to feel stupid about - those tuners are generally really good, and pretty much bullet proof... They're typically nickle plated instead of chrome, and can look really grubby - but clean up nicely with a little effort... Here's my '76 headstock: