Hi All, I did a search on this topic but came up empty...if any of you know of threads like this, please let me know. I was curious what types of tonal differences one would get from a 51P pickup than a J pickup in the neck position of a two single coil pickup bass. Listening to some Police/Sting songs (Every Breath You Take, St. Augustine in Hell, Canary In a Coal Mine, Man In A Suitcase...please let me know if any of these weren't the 51P) that one 51P single coil sounds a bit fatter than a solo'd J neck pickup. I love my Jazz bridge pickup, but want more beef than what I have currently, but less beef than a true split-coil P...and I like single coil punch. Also, is what is the difference in location measured from the nut for a 51P pickup on a '51 Pbass and a J pickup in a Jbass in the neck position? Thanks everyone!!!