I've read a good bit on this topic already but I was wondering if any of you big handed players have made the trasition from say a precision to jazz without the cramping/ discomfort I often hear about and have experienced. I would appreciate some feedback b/c I am thinking of getting this jazz bass that I really liked but am concerned as to the neck/comfort? Thanks.
I dont have huge hands but have played a precision and 5 strings for the past4 years and just got an ibanez SRX650 the neck is tiny compared to what I'm used to. I haven't had any real problems yet. It's really comfortable but in a weird kind of way. Like dr.schols inserts. Takes some getting used to.
I do the caveman thumb around the neck thing even on my wide 5-string. So on the narrow necks, for me there's definitely no avoiding it! I don't know - I guess I like 'em all shapes and sizes. If it plays and sounds good, I'll deal.
I've never experienced hand cramping, on 5 strings, P basses, Js, Ricks, Ibanez, etc and I have huge hands. I think cramping would be more of a sign of poor technique.
I went from playing only 6 string basses to playing only Jazz basses, imagine that for a shock! Apart from the fact that my left hand technique is gone i never had a problem. Just take it slowly and give your hand the time to get used to it...
I have fairly big hands, and prefer small necks. My Vigier has the best neck I've ever played on any bass, and it is slim and small in every way. Cramps shouldn't occur unless you're trying to break the neck with your left hand...an easy touch is all it takes.
Nothing like that - just a temporary bit of claustrophobia. (More so with a short-scale.) If there's cramping and/or pain, something is very wrong that has nothing to do with nut width IMHO. (Like LH technique and/or string action.) If people can manage on a mandolin, you can manage on a Jazz bass.