Hey all! I'm looking for a new bass and trying to decide what to go for. I am a beginner and currently have a Yamaha TRBX174 that I picked up on sale earlier this year. I love the tone of it save for one issue. The body is too small. I'm a tall guy (6'8) and I just can't seem to get comfortable with my plucking hand, and I'm assuming that is due to my larger-than-normal wing span. So I have come to the conclusion that I need an upgrade and that the smaller, modern style bodies aren't for me. I've played a few different Fenders at my local guitar center and the Jazz bass style body seems so much more comfortable to me. So after some research, I've decided to try out the Sire basses (though I am open to other suggestions). I'm inclined to go for the V7 because of the Fenders I have tried out, but I'm also interested in the versatility of the PJ style pups on the P7. I am just worried that the body style of the P may give me similar problem with comfort that I am currently having with the yamaha. I wish I could actually try out both of the basses but unfortunately it would be quite the drive to make it to an authorized dealer for me (I'm in SC). So basically my question is, am I crazy for even worrying about this? Have any fellow giant bass players had issue like this? Or am I making a problem out of nothing and just need to man up and get used to it? Any input or recommendation would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!
I'm average size but the jazz bass body is large and it makes a lot of sense to me that you'd feel more comfortable with one. You may feel at home with a 35" scale jazz bass of some sort.
Reverend Thundergun might just be perfect for you, in more ways than one. Made me forget all about Fender basses. I can't tell you how many times I've heard people say the Music Man Bongo is a huge bass, it might just be good for you, but it costs twice what the Thundergun does.
Pino's your size (height). Check out what he's playing, I be surprised if comfort wasn't a consideration for him.
I think string spacing sounds like your main issue. When I think about big tall guys playing bass, I think next about average-height guys playing standard guitars. They feel like toys to me (and I'm not a guy, and only 5'6) but those guys are bigger than I am and get used to playing them. So, I think it can be done, but with large fingers you'd want to get the widest possible spacing at the bridge. Hope this helps.
While I'm not as tall as the OP (I'm 6' 4"), I also find the full-size jazz bodies more comfortable. If you're looking for a 5-string, I would recommend Lakland's Joe Osborn/55-60.
Not sure if this is too far out tonally, but a Modulus Quantum or G Gould might fit the bill. 35" scale and somewhat larger body.
I don’t know if your height/frame matters what size bass you need. I say this only because Greg Lake was 6’2” and Chris Squire was 6’4” Play what fits you and is comfortable Not all 34” scale basses are the same overall length since the bodies vary and placement of the neck on the body also varies. I never played one but I’ve heard the Gibson Thunderbird was on the long side ? Best of luck finding what works for you.
You didn’t mention a budget, and neither of these options are cheap, but you might consider Super P | Dingwall Guitars Or 20th Anniversary Quake Bass – Kalium Music
You could go the Krist Novoselic route. He was 6 foot 7 and rocked the Gibson Ripper and RD pretty good!
I’m the same way. I’m over 6’ and hate the way small basses look like a bow tie on me. Traditional style 5 string basses are normally larger bodied. Like Jazz and P 5’s, Stingray 5’s. My favorite would be the Modulus Genesis 5 because it has an even bigger body. There are options.
I’m only 6’ but I’m a big guy and I understand where you’re coming from. I’ve had a few basses that I didn’t like how their small body wasn’t as comfortable or being smaller made me look more overweight than I actually am. I have big enough arms and hands for bigger basses so that’s what I’ve come to like lately. I’d recommend a Mexican fender. I picked up my Mexican jazz 5 for $400 new on sale. You may eventually want to give Dingwall or other longer 35-37 inch scale basses a shot also. I’ve never had a bass that’s more comfortable for me than my dingwall. But it is way more expensive than an import fender or Sire. Small people sometimes even complain about the dingwalls scale being too extreme. As you can see it’s actually a good size for me.
Thanks for all the replies! As far as budget goes it is flexible. I can easily save up for a while longer, I'm not in a rush necessarily. I do feel like jumping for a Dingwall (while I would love too and they seem like a great solution) would be a bit much. I'm definitely still a beginner so not sure I can justify that to myself haha. Around $1000-$1200 is probably where I'd wanna max out at