• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Any one else unable to pick a clear #1 bass?

Well, there's the one that I sold. Sadowsky M5/24, koa/mahogany with ebony board. Should have just subbed the pickups with Nordstrand Big Splits. Otherwise, it's a toss-up among a Sadowsky Metro Will Lee 5 that got some after-market love from Pat Wilkins and the NYC shop, a Carl Pedigo custom (looks like a Lakland 55-01, but 34" scale, Duncan NYC soaps and John East pre with variable mids, and an Xotic XB-2. This last one was unplayably backbowed when I got it, but I did the setup myself and it came out well - and this axe is built as well as any NYC Sadowsky/MTD/Alembic that I've ever owned or played. I'm not in love with the body shape - wide bouts don't work for my short-waisted build - but it is a fabulous sounding axe - deep authoritative fundamental, but plenty of shimmer and sheen depending on hand placement, plucking technique and knob manipulation. I have not yet had it side-by-side with the WL5 (I have two locations), but that XB-2 might really be "the one..." If I could only have one. Honorable Mention - an old Yamaha BB2000 fretless that just plain sings, thumps, and brings it. Too bad it's only 4 strings!
 
Hey man, life is too short to not own whatever you want and no excuse is needed to keep them all if you can!

I am so impressed with the basses is see at TalkBass and would love to own more but im short scale with real 'hand issues' at soon to be 62 years.

I have long scale covered easily; P and J types etc, i do fretwork setups etc pretty well myself....my problem is finding another shorty to compliment my 65 Epi Newport and cheap Bronco (modded, really nice neck) and keeping the bass under say 7 1/2 lbs.
 
9B2C2E29-C3E7-4AA8-82E2-04CBE72EDE69.jpeg

This question seems to come up a lot in many different forms. However I always have to reply and post a picture of my #1. I always have more basses but they come and go, this one always stays as my favourite.
 
My number ones change depending on the job.
If I need to do an contemporary R&B gig, my musicman 5 is my #1
For blues and rock, four string all the way. (Just because they're fun to rip on)
For travel (fly outs) I go to my headless.
For jazz, it would be an upright (if I owned one)
If I had to choose only one right now, it would probably be my Sandberg TM-4 ultralight.
It's just so light and easy to play

p.s. @lowdownthump I WANT THAT CAPRICE! ❤️❤️❤️
D091B83C-125D-4ED8-BDCB-3D8160480E49.jpeg
1D971234-E906-4473-978E-D07AAD716399.jpeg
BE0FF704-22AD-4538-AA14-88FE2D0384EE.jpeg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lowdownthump