Hey guys. I was recently told that I shouldn't use a Hofner for country, but prior I was told by several people it'd be fine. I own a P-Bass, and plan to use it a lot, but I intend to use the Hofner just as much. I know the P is the more typical country tone being as it's so punchy (The Hofner not as much). I'd love to hear your opinions!
Agree..whatever sounds good to you. I remember seeing John Prine in Dublin a couple of years back...his bassist used a Danelectro Longhorn as his only bass all night, sounded great to me!
Anybody trying to tell you what bass to play is feeding you bu!!$#!+. I live near Branson, Missouri, which has many music shows geared towards "country." With that, and all the weekend bar gigs I've played over the years, here are the basses I've played, personally, for "Country" gigs over the past 35 years: no-name P-bass copy with a J-bass nut width neck when I was in high school (the USA equivalent of UK O- and A- levels) Fender Am Std P-bass 1975 J-bass 1976 Rickenbacker 4001 1981 Rickenbacker 4002 several borrowed basses over the years, or basses I was working on for other guys to make sure they were gig-ready (including a P-bass copy that had been painted in John Deere (the farm implement company) green, complete with decals and toy tractor tires added to the control knobs for effect Mustang bass (also short-scale) Double bass My custom fanned-fret P-style bass with narrowed string spacing and a Rickenbacker HB-2 pickup (see my thread on my custom bass in the Luthier's corner) And probably more that I can't remember right now. FINALLY -- The Beatles,with Ringo singing, recorded the Buck Owens' song "Act Naturally," with Sir Paul playing the bass parts with his Hofner, and he recorded his Wings song "Sally G" (definitely country-styled with the pedal steel guitar in the mix) with his Rickenbacker 4001. It's not the instrument, it's the player. Add a little bit of bridge pickup into the primarily neck pickup tone of the Hofner mix for a little more presence and you'll be just fine.
That's the way I felt about it. I have the Hofner in lay-away and planned to start using it for the most part (the P-Bass is a bit too large for me). It's modern country, so, typical country standards tend to go out the window.
Yeah, Paul is my idol. So much of his stuff is super country sounding, and he used the Hofner on a good portion of it.
I brought my Hofner Club to rehearsal and the lead singer/song writer/rhythm player said "What'd you bring that for? I like the sound of your Active 5 string!" After rehearsal, I gave him the cd of 14 songs we went through. Funniest thing, next day he called and said "That sounded pretty good!" Hey no SxxT. To echo others, find the sound that excites you and makes you happy!
This seems to be a discussion mainly about basses, so I'll move it there from the General Instruction forum where it was started (for reasons that I don't understand).
Personally, I think a Hofner strung up with flats would be great for country music. The only thing is the look, and musicians and audiences alike might have a funny reaction to it. But if you want to be a maverick, go for it. I know the tone will be fine, because I own three Hofner violin basses, and though I've never used them for country, I've used my Fender Coronado (with flats) and it is virtually the same bass in terms of electronics, scale, etc. The Coronado sounded awesome, and so will the Hofner (with flats).
Use whatever you want... I've been known to use a 90's Kramer pointy headstock bass and a BC Rich Warlock in my country rock band... The are naYsayers in every genre!!! I used a Steinberger or Status headless basses in a death metal band just because the singer hated them