Looking to get a '51 P Bass. Are the only reasonable true and accurate options the old CIJ models and current Custom Shop models? It's too bad that they didn't make the Sting bass in butterscotch.
I was playing my mint 94 CIJ yesterday, what a killer bass, I was running through my huge pedal board and it was dead quiet.
The MIJ butterscotch isn't. It's more like a slightly see-through TV yellow. They sound and play great, though.
I loved the CV Squier one I tried last year. I wish I could have bought it. It sounded great even though it was a little heavy. The *real* 51 I tried 20 years ago was a killer bass in all respects and the Squier didn't remotely compare, but I'm a lot more likely to actually afford the Squier. The 90's MIJ basses I've never had the pleasure of messing with. How accurate are they, really? Do they have the same neck shape as the original?
You might also check out the Rob Allen Solid 4, which is a very close approximation of the early 50s P-basses.
I'm not some normal of vintage specialist but the neck of mine in the pictures above feels like just a modern neck with a medium width nut. I don't want to appear bashing these MIJs. They are great, but not nearly as accurate as e.g. the Fender Japan '57 P-basses. The color is off and the neck shape is better (for many).
I just looked at your blog and saw the '62 AVRI CAR with wear on it. Are you it's new owner? I thought I saw this exact bass on eBay this week? Feel free to reply by private message if you care to. As to your question, the 1991 or so Made in Japan '51 Precision reissue basses are great instruments. Prices have crept up quite a bit but they are much closer in spec to the original early basses than the later Crafted in Japan instruments. Like the Custom Shop basses, the early MIJ basses have the larger ferrules, faithful reproductions of the neck shape and tuners and the color is closer than the CIJ's school bus yellow color.
Thanks! Yes - I was very surprised to see the prices of the early 90's MIJ 51's. They're in the $1,200 range. For that type of price I'd like to see a nitro finish. I definitely would like a vintage correct neck. Fatties rock! Yes - I am the '82 CAR's new owner. The seller ended up being in the next town over from an area I was visiting that holiday weekend and we worked a cash deal. It was meant to be. She's doing great and will be on stage with me tomorrow night.
Wow, nice! Congrats! I am waiting for a '62 Fullerton RI in fiesta red to pop up. One sold very recently on eBay for an appallingly low price of $1425 I believe. I would have snapped it right up if I had been more vigilant.
If that's appalling then what I paid for my CAR would make you vomit. I got very lucky (negotiation helped, too). Best of luck with your search.
1991 Fender MIJ '51 Reissue. Picture is a little washed out, but not much. The picture is pretty close to the actual color. This one has a "Muy Grande" Rio Grande pickup. Note: some guys used to spin those '51 bridge covers so the mute wouldn't make contact. You'll see pictures with those covers on backwards. I think either way is acceptable.