Convert 4 string to 5 string (or not) dilema

Did one myself...
Begining of the project -

Finished project -

Overall it was pretty easy to do. I have built several basses before, so I had no problems in that department. I did get some help from Ric5 on different parts and had to pick up some files for the nut.
Other than that, it was fun and it came out really well for my first go around. Looking to do a Fender P at some point as well.

 

I wouldn't do it. For a very short while I owned a Tacoma Thunderchief "5 string". I put that in quotes because it was just a four string onto which they crammed an additional string; it had the same neck as the four string version. The strings were so close together that I couldn't get my fingers between them even down at the bridge. I packed it up and sent it back the same day.

If you play with a pick it might work for you, but otherwise, I'd just look for an affordable five string.

 

If you 'love' the bass, don't mess up a good relationship. Find a cheap fiver.

 

Find a 5 string to at least see if you use the B enough to warrant doing it.

If you can afford it, why not así the builder to build you a 5 string versión?

 

A Hipshot Bass Xtender will let you extend the low range of your bass without extensive, irreversible changes.

http://store.hipshotproducts.com/cart.php?m=product_list&c=6

 

Honestly, do as you want. I had fun. I also did not spend much money at all. Bass cost $125. Conversion parts - $50.. Again, what everyone is saying is true. Play a 5'er to know what you like or don't like about them. I have 20+ basses. This was not a difficult choice for me. I also know what I wanted. The bass I converted was not the bass I should have done. 1-1/2" nut is really narrow. Should have done it with a bigger nut width. However, I have a blast playing the bass. I can't wait to try it again. If you are looking for a super narrow string spacing on a 5'er, there are very few basses out there that have that kind of spacing and a narrower neck at the heal, but there are not many.

 

oh, BTW - I just bought another P style bass to convert to a 5'er. All in cost $47 for the bass and all the parts to complete..

 

I've got a 4 string body I'm thinking of trying to jam a 5 string neck on to - I figure if I trim the base of the neck 1/4" on each side, do a depth (from the back) a tad deeper than the pocket, then match the butt shape, it should work - anyone done this? Foolish thing to attempt?

 

I suppose you could do what I did with my Carvin LB-20, and string it BEAD. This is a "before" picture; it's currently wearing the 70-135s out of a 5er set of LaBella Black Tapewounds. And it works just fine; just required a slight truss rod tweek, and a new nut.

 

Hmm. I wouldn't do it if you enjoy the bass as it currently is.