I'm sure it's happened to everyone at least once. You learn some new tunes that you think will be a hit with the crowd, but to your surprise when you're done playing them you can hear the crickets chirping. The song was a flop. Not that the band played it badly, just the crowd didn't react to it the way you anticipated. On the other hand, the songs you really don't think will be a hit get a great reaction from the crowd. Our song that was a flop was "Crawling" by Hoobastank, and the hit was "Voodoo" by Godsmack. Anyone else want to share their hits and flops? If nothing else, this thread may help us cover bands get some ideas for new material that seems to work well for others.