My first bass was a MIM Fender P. I hated the big chunky neck on it so I swapped it out with a Jazz neck. Shortly afterwards I discovered short scales, and have mostly been playing short and medium scales since. I was at a jam a couple weeks ago and decided to bring the Frankenbass and after a few minutes it felt pretty good. I've been playing it a lot lately, but I'm starting to wish the neck was thicker. I'm pretty surprised by this because I've been avoiding P necks like the plague, and have declared my hate for them several times here on TB. I guess I'm ready to try a P neck again. Has anyone had a similar experience, and how did it work out for you?