Edit: It all boils down to one question - what, in your opinion, is more important (regarding practical use): Having a fiver, or having a P? I'm committed to not keep more than three basses at a time.... One is on order, and consequentely, one has to go. Not much of a problem. But I have Sadowsky 5-Sting J Sadowsky 4 string P/J Yamaha 4-string fretless (self made epoxy fingerboard, and my first bass) On order is a Sadowsky 4-string J. So I am contemplating wether I'll let go the Sadowsky 5, and take the Hipshot Detuner route for lower notes. The other option is to sell the P/J, and to rely on J's only. Selling the fretless is the least attractive, since it has much emotional value to me... And the 4-stringed Jazz on order is meant to stay, since I don't want to be without a 4-string Jazz...... So: Would you let go the fiver or the P/J 4?