Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Basses [BG]' started by bryan17, Jul 14, 2005.
I LIKE THEM BOTH. CAN SOMEONE DO A COMPARISON?
Nordstrand has 10 letters and F Bass has 5 letters in the name.
Nordstrand would be more custom. Typically F basses are ash/maple but you can "upgrade" to an ash/ebony combo for the fretted types. Also the electronics package is standard F equipment
Nordstrand has a much more open approach to letting you choose all of the aspects of your bass (within reason I suppose). You can choose your pickups and pre (including the F pre) and body woods etc. from a wide variety of sources. Carey would also help guide your choices.
Basically if you like the F sound you have to get the F. If not, the Nordstrand would definitely be worth looking into. I think he is by far the best of the "up and coming" builders.
Its probably also worth noting that an F-Bass is designed to be the proverbial "j-bass on steriods", whereas a Nordstrand can be whatever you commission it to be.
As such, if the j-bass is your thing, but you want a less traditional design and features (ie three band preamp, piezo bridge etc) then Fbass might be a good option.
That's it...in a nutshell!
F=10 letters also!sort of.
F basses rock!!!
F Basses DO rock! so do Nordstrands! I own both and I can tell you that in the case of MY basses, the F Bass definitely has the Jazz on steroids thing going on and the Nordstrand has, for lack of a better term believe me, because I don't mean to link these two luthiers, more of a Fodera-ish type tone. Both play like a dream, my Nordie is an absolute gem.
I own three basses:
A Nordstrand, an F Bass and a Sadowsky ( just so i can be accepted in this forum )
you have picked two of the best builders on the planet, you can't go wrong. In fact , these guys are friends.
Come to Vegas and you can check them out
I prefer the feel and sound of my Fbass. The only likening to a jazz is when the bridge pup is full on and neck pup 30% or in single coil mode. I have made my F sound like a thumpy pbass or a bright rick tone with a pick among other things with the preamp. So IMO the F will be more versitile in sound and easier to find used, and sometimes cheaper in price.
Nordies are awesome and you could go custom in the neck shape, or even get an Fbass preamp in it if you want. The wait for a custom bass would kill me though. Thats what broke the decision between the same two models for me about a year ago.
I wouldn't classify a Fbass as a jazz bass on steroids, at least the ones I've ever come in contact with. They lack some output in the pickup department, so to me, you can't make the steroid comment with Fbass, but rather you can say it's a modern take on a jazz bass. Plus, the Fbass can do more than just a jazz bass even though it certainly has that vibe to it. The Sadowsky to me has a jazz bass on steroids vibe to it though.
All this F-Bass talk... I can't take it!! Adrian, did you receive my BN6 yet?
waiting.. should be here before i go to rehearsal and a gig
i wonder if i will make a lot of mistakes on a 6 tonight!!
kidding again, bro- if i put a scratch on that thing you will come out and personally beat my arse...
No worries, I'd take it as being officially broken in. I was serious if you want to test it out... unless you can ship it today of course.
bro- you dont want it shipped today even if it comes in time- it will sit over the weekend in 114 degree weather! i will get it out to you monday.
Yes, you are correct. I forgot how brutal it is out there... but is it at least 'dry heat'?
I agree... I've never seen F Basses exhibit mood swings or complain of shriveled testicles.
For me the best Jazz basses on steroids have been... Fender Jazzes. Some are better than others. They're the only basses that truly nail the magical "J" sound... though my F Bass studio comes very, very close
Carey Nordstrand and George Furlanetto both make excellent basses. All depends on what you want.
I always play my F Bass BN5's in Single Coil Mode. The output is boosted noticeably in SC mode compared to the humbucker mode.
When I play Fingerstyle in Single Coil Mode, I adjust the bridge PU to 100%, the front PU anywhere from zero to 50%. (dual volume knobs) I adjust the midrange control from halfway to 100% (it's VERY musical even at 100%), with the Passive tone control dialed down from 20% to 50%. I NAIL a Fender Jazz sound that is the stuff dreams are made of. Can you say Jaco tones? Oh My! It seriously growls with that punchy mid-range, Jaco-esque, burpy mid tone. I can almost make it sound like a fretless when I place my right hand close to the bridge.
then, if I dial up both pickups evenly, dial down the midrange control, Passive tone all the way up, I nail Marcus Miller Glassy, sweet slap tones. This bass is all that in ONE instrument!
F Bass = Sonic Nirvana! (for me) Plays so nice too. The neck is fast and very comortable.
You can get a deep, big, full, round almost P-Bass vibe as well. My F Bass is simply the most versatile bass I've ever owned and played. Gary
I've never had the opportunity to try a Nordie before, despite having heard so many wonderful things about Carey's work, but all I can say is I have never looked back after acquiring my F-bass !!!
The comments on the tone and presence of the F-bass from my bass-playering friends, other musicians and the PA guys have been consistently very encouraging.
Also just as important, the ergonomics (in addition to the tone) of the instrument just continues to inspire effortless playing, hour after hour, day after day, month after month...
Just two cents from an extremely satisfied F-bass owner.
Funny you say that... I won a contest on the Fbass board to guess what "BN" meant in George's model numbers... it was "Bass Nirvana"
So there you go.
Very cool!!! I always wondered what BN meant and now I know!