Where would you get the idea that they are similar? F Basses, generally, are geared to be jazz basses on steroids, with almost all of them having ash bodies, maple necks and boards, the same body shape (for fretteds), and proprietary electronics/pickups. The cost of a "standard" F Bass is quite reasonable, but options that go out of the ordinary are usually very costly; this is likely to sway buyers into sticking with the known formula that works so well. Fodera offers a wide range of body shapes, pickups, electronics, spacings, woods, and just about everything else. There are multiple Fodera "sounds," and even then I wouldn't count on any particular Fodera having that sound as each bass is so customizable. Fodera is more about giving the customer exactly what they want. F Bass is more about doing one specific thing extremely well.
Agreed 95%, I'm not sure if the cost of an F-Bass is "quite reasonable." Ford?!? Respectfully disagree.
Not sure what an unmodified 5-string F goes for nowadays, but they used to be at around high $2k/low $3k back when I was looking, which I consider reasonable for a handmade bass. They could be crazy amounts more now for all I know though.
And I didn't know most of that, which is why I asked. Thanks! The reason I compared the two is because they're both "boutique", and because some of the Fodera models like kind of like F bass models.
Never heard or played an FBass that I didn't love. Never heard or played a Fodera that moved me. I am not saying either isn't superbly crafted and yes Fodera offers many more options but the FBass always were almost impossible to put down IMO.
Absurd. The F Bass build quality is equal to that of Fodera, and at a lower price point. They are, however, very different basses. F Basses typically have a more aggressive, throaty voice (ala a J on steroids as Bryan said), rich in the low mids. Certainly, wood choice will make a difference (if you're a believer in that) but, generally speaking, I would characterize Foderas as being a little more reserved, perhaps more even across the spectrum. More on this when I get my mahogany/koa/ebony Viceroy, which I'm thinking will be more mid-focused than my walnut/maple/ebony Emperor. Whichever brand you buy, you will have a first-rate, premium instrument.