I am thinking about replacing the pickups in my Pau Ferro Player Precision, looking for a warmer, but still clear tone. So far, I have tried the EMG GZR, but looking for a little more mellow warmth. Maybe the Aguilar AG P4-60 is a good fit. Looking forward to hearing about your experience replacing the PUs in a Player P. Was it worth it? Btw., current strings are light GHS Precision Flats (3025).
Funny, the Pure Vintage '63 (that is stock in the American Original P) was number #1 on my list, until I read too many bad reviews about them being too muddy. I even have the Pure Vintage '64 in my Jazz Bass, could not stop thinking about them after playing a Flea Roadworn at a store once. So after your unison answers, I finally ordered the PV '63 an hour ago. Thanks for helping me make up my mind!
For warm I would say AG P4-60, Seymound Duncan Antiquity II and Fender Pure Vintage 63. With this last pickup you will get warm, bassy and punchy. If you are getting too much bass, lower your pickups a tad to tame them. It works well with this pickup because it's relatively hot.
Thanks. I think I'll try them in this order, would like to try the Antiquity earlier, but it's the most expensive. Fender Pure Vintage '63 Aguilar AG 4P-60 Seymour Duncan SPB-1 Seymour Duncan P Antiquity II But I really hope I like the PV 63, going to install it today...