I've had a Fender Rumble 15 for about four years and I was getting very tired of the sound. I use it strictly for practice. I tried to get rid of it... posted it for as low as $25 on Craigslist and didn't sell. GC wouldn't give me even a lollypop for it. Then. I stumbled onto some threads by people buying Ampeg BA-108's and replacing the speaker with the Eminence Alpha 8a, which sells new for $49.99. So I could buy the Ampeg BA-108 used (about $60 if you can find it), or new ($100), and then replace the speaker (another $50). So, I ordered the Eminence and put it in the Rumble. Then I said, what the heck, I'm going to port the little thing and see what happens. So I ordered one of those flared 2" port kits from precision. After doing some calculations, I "thought" I was shooting for 45Hz... but I measured wrong... and after cutting the hole on the side I found out that the inside flare would not fit because it bumps into the speaker. So I had to extend the tube... right now it's about 11.5"... I forgot, so it's tuned to around 35Hz, if my calculations where right. (I estimated the volume of the enclosure at .574 ft^3.) I also lined some of the sides of the speaker with AC filter foam (I had some and it was a last minute decision). And if it matters, the foam is black. Ok, I put everything back together. Here's how it looks like now. Results? Less distortion. More clarity. The notes on the B string on my 5er sound better. Overall I'd say it sounds better. Before I just hated the sound going straight into the amp so I always ran a BDDI in front of it. Now I just plug straight into the amp. I's say the mod was a success. Was it worth it? Well, that's subjective. But I did learn a thing or two in the process so that was definitely a plus.
Nice first DIY project! Seems like you learned some useful things and achieved your goal of getting improved sound quality. A few model runs suggest that you can pick up a few db in the 50-90Hz range by tuning a little higher (mid-50's). This will actually improve the sound of the b-string by strengthening the 2nd harmonic. Just notch out the internal flare so its not touching the speaker. Or just have fun with it as-is...
Nice post, I see plenty of those amps and wonder if it would be a good investment for an amp to do acoustic coffee shop gigs. Great to hear it's working well for you!
Thx Astro and Thunda for your comments. I initially thought of tuning to 50. Per your (Astro's) analysis the B string would have benefitted more from that 2nd harmonic boost. But it's pretty good as it is... And I suspect primarily because the Eminence is so much superior than the stock speaker in every way. Considering that this is a practice amp I'm going to leave well enough alone, that is, until the time I feel the itch to tinker with it again. Right now I'm set. Vanilla, some people are buying Ampeg BA108's and replacing the speaker with the Eminence. I found a thread where someone put a 10" speaker in the BA108. If I was starting from scratch, I'd probably go the Ampeg route, but since I already had the Fender and I couldn't get rid of it I was willing to bear the risk of thrashing the amp. But it turned out nice and I think it would do fine in an acoustic setting. I would do it again if I found a Rumble pretty cheap... Perhaps someone even has one that is not using it and would be willing to give it away.
Nice driver replacement.I have done a similar job with Eminence Alpha 8A in 2008. Marshall MB 15. Sound MUCH better and can handle more low.Finally sold to a guitarlist who like the MEATY tone from this MB15. BOY_0144 by totomoyap, on Flickr