I have always loved P bass tone, and so I have owned mostly P basses in the relatively short time I've been playing bass. Now that I am ready to move to 5 strings, though, I find myself liking the J bass style more and more... the new P5 looks a bit...out of place, as if that 5th string was forced in there. Don't get me wrong, I definitely want to keep that fat P tone (which, by the way, stays alright on the low B or is does a trebly J tone keep it tighter?). Has anyone else found themselves liking the J shape for 5 more than a P shape for 5? Or is the J shape overdone and more P's are needed? Thanks for reading! ***If you choose something else, don't vote and let us know what you would pick in a reply. Thanks.