Im in a heated discussion with a guitarist friend of mine about fretless guitars. He says it wouldn't work but can't think of a reason and I say there is no reason why it wouldn't work. Any thoughts?
Check out Tim Donahue (not Jerry!). He plays fretless guitar with flawless intonation, even with chords. http://www.geocities.com/fretlessguitarist/tim_donahue.html http://www.allrightnow.com/fws/timd/tditl1.htm
I made one, and I love it! The sound isn't very present, but it is very unique. Chording is strange because you get used to "cheating" to play certian chords, and when your fingers have to be exactly on the line, it can be a problem. It is also interesting with chords to find how much better in tune you can make them. Stopping all the beats but still having the open strings in tune is a wonderfull sound. Lee
Vigier in Europe have been making fretless guitars for quite a while - Guitarist magazine have been carrying adverts for the "Surfretter" guitar for about 2 years now. Here is a link to an interview with Ron Thal (?) about playing this guitar : http://www.guitarist.co.uk/interviews/inter_page.asp?ID=3762&PageNo=7
Some guys who play or have played fretless guitars: Phillip Catherine Randy Roos the guys in the fusion band Kittyhawk (forget their names, they also played Chapman Sticks) Frank Zappa Dan Stearns, a local guy here in MA the guy in the Moors (another local MA player)
I wasn't aware of Frank Zappa ever playing a fretless guitar. I know Adrian Belew (who played with Zappa in the '70s), and Robert Fripp have both played fretless guitar.
Check the liner notes to "Shut Up and Play Your Guitar", he uses a fretless Acoustic Black Widow on a few of the cuts.