So I played my fretless P live for the first time last night. I enjoyed it immensely. I even had someone say I should play fretless through the whole set. Here's my problem. The fretless works great for the quieter stuff, like backing acoustic, lap steel or banjo, but when the guitar player switches to electric I find that I don't have the punch or presence I would like to have. I'm running flats on the fretless, so maybe recommend a fretless that will stand up to rounds. I still want the fretless P sound, just with the ability to punch through in a loud rock setting.