I have this theory that sunburst finishes sound better than solid finishes. It may sound stupid, but I have a good reason to believe this. I was watching a tour of the Fender USA factory. During the tour, they said they chose which pieces of wood were good enough for sunburst, and which pieces would get a solid finish. Beautiful pieces of wood also have good tonal qualities, such as tight grain, consistancy, few or no deviations in the grain, etc. So, to sum it up, my theory is as follows: "Sunburst finishes, which have exposed grain, have better quality tone woods." I'm looking for a lutheirs thought on this.
Pretty much...if I'm right, the more exposed the grain is, the better the sound. Sunburst uses color, but natural finishes show the wood straight-up, so they may have even better wood, so if you get the same model, with the same quality neck and electronics, in sunburst and natural, the natural may sound better.
Also worth mentioning, the sunburst finishes won't have any filler, since the grain is exposed. The solid finishes may use filler if the wood is not perfect.....
Lose the "glue lines" sarcasm. This is based on wood quality, not the look of the instrument. My theory is as follows: Better wood = Better tone, and Exposed grain = Better wood. NOT Pretty finish = Better tone.
They base the color of the instrument on the appearance of the wood, not how it sounds. 'Tis true that a manufacturer will probably hide a poor quality piece under a solid color. They're all going to sound about the same coming out of your amplifier.
No sarcasm intended and I wasn't talking about looks. I seriously doubt you can tell the difference between a sunburst versus solid color J bass but if you can you have a talented ear.
Sorry....seriously thought you were being sarcastic. As far as noticing the difference, it probably isn't very noticable, if at all. I just think there is a difference there....that, and the "filler" comment earlier. filler diminishes tone.
Your "thoery" is predicated on this statement, but I don't think this is a valid connection to draw necessarily.
All a sunburst finish does is use darker tinted finish to help hide where the top veneer joins the body. The "tops" youre referring to are actually a thin veneer especially on factory guitars, thin and cheap they leave an undesirable thin edge where the body and veneer meet. The sunburst finish has no effect on "tone" This is by far the most ridiculous thing I've read on this forum to date.
I don't know, Scotty, a while ago there was a guy who pulled out his truss rod and filled the cavity with BBs... tough to beat that one. Can't find the thread, but it was head-scratching hilarity.
He removed his truss rod and filled the cavity with BB's? Wow, that almost makes my thread seem good..... "Mommy, I can't adjust my neck relief. What's wrong?"
Also, not all sunburst models use a vaneer, I know what your talking about, but that only applies to some models. There ARE some sunburst models without a vaneer.
Oh man, I found it! http://www.talkbass.com/forum/showthread.php?t=80794 And here's this from the very same day... http://www.talkbass.com/forum/showthread.php?t=80798