Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Miscellaneous [BG]' started by Matt R Miller, Jan 24, 2004.
what makes a top AAAAA vs. only AAA?
Depends on how much you're willing to pay.
One luthiers AAA is anothers AAAAAA is anothers AAAA
Lots of factors here:
Regularity of curl pattern
Density of figure
Depth of figure
Strong color differentiation
Check this out for instance:
I got this tonight on ebay.
While this could easily be called AAAAA, there was another piece from the same board that sold last week that was slightly better and sold for $20 more. So it sort of depending on what you're comparing it to.
cool! what are you planning on making with it?
That is by far the ugliest, nastiest, most unsightly piece of carpeting i've seen.
I installed the same stuff in my grandparents house, they love it. Must be a grandma thing. Besides, who wants to spend a few grand on flooring when there is gear to buy?
Damn! What carpet?!!
Unfortunately, there really isn't any industry "standard" or definatively objective grading/rating system when it comes to tops. The process is largely subjective and it all depends on the individual who is selling the piece. For instance, a AAAAA top graded by Carvin might be a AAAA top for Gibson. A top that Gibson would rate as AAAAA might not even be considered AAA by Keith Roscoe, etc. When it comes to tops, it's important to know the standards of the person you're dealing with (get a feel for what s/he considers average, premium, and exhibition grade) and try to get photos before you buy, if possible. Hope that helps!
Carvin's flamed and quilted maple used to be listed in their catalogs as AAA. Recently, they started calling it AAAA. I asked them if it was better wood, or a misprint, or just what the difference was. I was told that there was no difference in the wood they were offering. Their supplier changed their rating system.
So, I guess it just depends on where you get it and who's doing the rating.
Oh, and since we're on the subject . . .
any lame excuse I can find to post pics of my AAAA quilted maple Carvin B4F
That's a good lookin' bass. I really like the matching flying "V" headstock .
That Carvin looks like a pool of water.
Just dive right in.
Nice bass BTW mgood.
IF it shows closeups of someone getting shot in the head or run over by a steam roller it's PG-13. If there are boobies though it's rated R.
Oh wait a minute....what was the question again?